SPIER & MACKAY - Official Affiliate Thread

[EddieK]

Is it possible to remove the extra part in a hidden placket?
I ordered some shirts with hidden placket apparently by accident. I wanted french placket, or even the standard one.
So I'm wondering if it's possible to change the placket or remove the part that hides the button

 

[XxLogo]

Follow up question: does this shirt look too short (or alternatively is too much cuff showing)? I find with the first shirt it goes too far down my palm.
View attachment 1472993 View attachment 1472994

If you want some shirt advice, it is best to take pictures without the jacket on first. One with the cuff buttoned, one with it unbuttoned. Both have a relaxed/normal arm posture like in these photos

 

[sdjackofclubs]

@spiermackay I apologize if this has been answered recently. When can we expect to see some new oxford shirts? And will there be any new colors? Thank you.

 

[hrv123]

Can anyone provide an unbiased, non-fanboy, review of previous years' iterations of the knitwear (assuming the new stuff is made with the same material and by the same factory)? While I love S&M's tailoring and think it offers great value for money, I have been quite disappointed by their other offerings with respect to quality of fabrics, construction and sizing. I've tried the polos, tshirts, hoodies and the balamacn. I'm obviously not expecting them to be comparable to the higher end knitwear makers, but looking to see how they compare to other sub $400 manufacturers like Howlin, Jamieson's of Shetland, etc.

 

[MisterrLovely]

Can anyone provide an unbiased, non-fanboy, review of previous years' iterations of the knitwear (assuming the new stuff is made with the same material and by the same factory)? While I love S&M's tailoring and think it offers great value for money, I have been quite disappointed by their other offerings with respect to quality of fabrics, construction and sizing. I've tried the polos, tshirts, hoodies and the balamacn. I'm obviously not expecting them to be comparable to the higher end knitwear makers, but looking to see how they compare to other sub $400 manufacturers like Howlin, Jamieson's of Shetland, etc.

I have a few sweaters from the prior season of S&M, and I think they are all very nice for the quality, and I enjoy the fit as well. I haven't experienced any pilling, except some on the neck of my rollneck, but that's due to some stubble, so it's to be expected. I'm not sure how they compare to those similarly priced retailers, but I think they're good sweaters overall.

 

[abantigen]

Can anyone provide an unbiased, non-fanboy, review of previous years' iterations of the knitwear (assuming the new stuff is made with the same material and by the same factory)? While I love S&M's tailoring and think it offers great value for money, I have been quite disappointed by their other offerings with respect to quality of fabrics, construction and sizing. I've tried the polos, tshirts, hoodies and the balamacn. I'm obviously not expecting them to be comparable to the higher end knitwear makers, but looking to see how they compare to other sub $400 manufacturers like Howlin, Jamieson's of Shetland, etc.

The fine merino wool sweaters and cardigans are great value. You can get the same sort of style from Uniqlo for even cheaper but SM is a step above in quality. I like them as basic layering pieces under sport coats or visually interesting outerwear.

I'm not a big fan of the cable knits though. I'm sure the quality is fine but merino wool has a slight sheen to it and the lack of texture doesn't work well with this style in my opinion.

 

[nqtri]

Seems like the polo coats are ready stock so someone must have got their Brown Herringbone Donegal? Can I get some real life pics? I'm close to just disregard the balmacaan and pull the trigger on this.

 

[mbb355]

Following up on the knitwear questions, are the cable knit crewnecks and rollnecks heavier than their "basic"/"solid" counterparts? I typically think of cable knit sweaters as a little heavier and chunkier than plain ones, but that's not always the case and not clear from the website. I see they're all 2-ply merino wool, so maybe that suggests they're all of equal weight, but would be nice to confirm. Thanks.

 

[mbb355]

(By the way, whoever said the camel knitwear is too yellow is spot-on; I much prefer a "colder" camel (although not taupe-level cold))

 

[wafflingwaffles]

what's the difference between 'sale' and 'clearance rack'

 

[masernaut]

what's the difference between 'sale' and 'clearance rack'

Clearance is final sale. And thus, lower prices.

 

[masernaut]

Following up on the knitwear questions, are the cable knit crewnecks and rollnecks heavier than their "basic"/"solid" counterparts? I typically think of cable knit sweaters as a little heavier and chunkier than plain ones, but that's not always the case and not clear from the website. I see they're all 2-ply merino wool, so maybe that suggests they're all of equal weight, but would be nice to confirm. Thanks.

Yes, they are chunkier. But not heavyweight.

 

[masernaut]

Can anyone provide an unbiased, non-fanboy, review of previous years' iterations of the knitwear (assuming the new stuff is made with the same material and by the same factory)? While I love S&M's tailoring and think it offers great value for money, I have been quite disappointed by their other offerings with respect to quality of fabrics, construction and sizing. I've tried the polos, tshirts, hoodies and the balamacn. I'm obviously not expecting them to be comparable to the higher end knitwear makers, but looking to see how they compare to other sub $400 manufacturers like Howlin, Jamieson's of Shetland, etc.

Well, the brands you mentioned are a completely different price range. If you want knitwear basics with the best bang-for-your buck, then S&M's knitwears are of good quality. I have multiple vnecks and turtlenecks and I am happy with them. They're slim, trim, length is great and the hand-feel is nice. Could you get it cheaper elsewhere? Totally. But cheaper = questionable and ethical garment production.

 

[emiratiAL]

Thanks for all the feedback on the overcoat fitting, much appreciated!

 

[chatelet]

Well, the brands you mentioned are a completely different price range. If you want knitwear basics with the best bang-for-your buck, then S&M's knitwears are of good quality. I have multiple vnecks and turtlenecks and I am happy with them. They're slim, trim, length is great and the hand-feel is nice. Could you get it cheaper elsewhere? Totally. But cheaper = questionable and ethical garment production.

My only gripe is that the neck opening on the V necks is too large and could be reduced about 30%. That was last FW, not sure this year.