SPIER & MACKAY - Official Affiliate Thread

[LookOutSpices]

Looking for some fit feedback on a 38R Contemporary, particularly the length. I’ve purchased a few items in this size and they overall fit me well, but I’m beginning to think the length of the 38R may be a little short on me. I’m about 5’11” or 11.5.” The jacket just barely covers my butt, and sometimes appears a little short in the front. I’m kind of on the fence. The 38L is only an extra 1.5 inches or so in length, but I’m wondering if that will be too much extra length. I do have fairly large hips, which may contribute to it looking short.

 

[wilcthree]

Looking for some fit feedback on a 38R Contemporary, particularly the length. I’ve purchased a few items in this size and they overall fit me well, but I’m beginning to think the length of the 38R may be a little short on me. I’m about 5’11” or 11.5.” The jacket just barely covers my butt, and sometimes appears a little short in the front. I’m kind of on the fence. The 38L is only an extra 1.5 inches or so in length, but I’m wondering if that will be too much extra length. I do have fairly large hips, which may contribute to it looking short.

View attachment 1472885 View attachment 1472886 View attachment 1472887

I recently switched from 38R contemporary to 38L contemporary and couldn't be happier. The touch of length and lowered buttoning point both compliment my frame well and make for a better silhouette. I'm 6ft. even and do not at all think the extra length of the 38L is an issue. In fact, it's quite the opposite, a welcomed improvement. I suggest going for it.

 

[loduN]

Here are some photos of it. Trying to sell it. Let me know if you’re interested in a 38L contemporary.

Thanks for the pictures.
I think that confirms what I was worried about. I'm no longer interested in this item but thanks anyway.

 

[LookOutSpices]

I recently switched from 38R contemporary to 38L contemporary and couldn't be happier. The touch of length and lowered buttoning point both compliment my frame well and make for a better silhouette. I'm 6ft. even and do not at all think the extra length of the 38L is an issue. In fact, it's quite the opposite, a welcomed improvement. I suggest going for it.

Appreciate the feedback!

One other question: how much can sleeves be shortened? I already have to shorten mine by about 3/4 of an inch, and the extra inch on the sleeves worries me.

 

[Ebichuman]

Appreciate the feedback!

One other question: how much can sleeves be shortened? I already have to shorten mine by about 3/4 of an inch, and the extra inch on the sleeves worries me.

Go for the Long and don't shorten your sleeves so much - they're bordering on too short right now as you're showing a good inch of your cuffs

 

[LookOutSpices]

Go for the Long and don't shorten your sleeves so much - they're bordering on too short right now as you're showing a good inch of your cuffs

Thanks, I agree on the sleeves, but I've realized the shirt is the problem, not the jacket. This shirt, despite being the same size as my others, measures slightly longer and hits considerably further down past my wrist. The others don't show nearly as much.

 

[Ebichuman]

Thanks, I agree on the sleeves, but I've realized the shirt is the problem, not the jacket. This shirt, despite being the same size as my others, measures slightly longer and hits considerably further down past my wrist. The others don't show nearly as much.

In my eyes the shirt length is spot on, not at all too long.

 

[Stylewords]

Thanks, I agree on the sleeves, but I've realized the shirt is the problem, not the jacket. This shirt, despite being the same size as my others, measures slightly longer and hits considerably further down past my wrist. The others don't show nearly as much.

The shirt is not the problem. Get the 38L.

 

[XxLogo]

Looking for some fit feedback on a 38R Contemporary, particularly the length. I’ve purchased a few items in this size and they overall fit me well, but I’m beginning to think the length of the 38R may be a little short on me. I’m about 5’11” or 11.5.” The jacket just barely covers my butt, and sometimes appears a little short in the front. I’m kind of on the fence. The 38L is only an extra 1.5 inches or so in length, but I’m wondering if that will be too much extra length. I do have fairly large hips, which may contribute to it looking short.

View attachment 1472885 View attachment 1472886 View attachment 1472887

As it stands right now, I suggest getting the 38L. Right now, it seems the jacket is too short and this is contributing to your legs looking longer than your body, when it should be about 50/50. As well as the sleeve length being a tad too short, should show no more than 1/2" of cuff personally as that is the sweet spot. Looks like you are showing about 1" right now... Otherwise it fits you great everywhere else.
As for shirt, if you are concerned, the sleeve should hit mid palm (widest part of hand) when unbuttoned, but if it say goes down to knuckles it is probably a bit long. Right now it looks like the shirt sleeve is perfect when buttoned, but since there is no unbuttoned pictures I can't really tell. The body also looks okay from pictures, but can't really tell with jacket on

 

[1st Step]

Thanks, I read your comments with interest.

Just to clarify, from what I read it sounds like you sized up for the coat, is that correct?

However, the S&M website is saying stick to your normal SC size.

Am I missing something, or has the cut and size changed??

size up!

 

[LookOutSpices]

Follow up question: does this shirt look too short (or alternatively is too much cuff showing)? I find with the first shirt it goes too far down my palm.

 

[Salad]

Does the chunky cardigan have a separate sizing that's not yet updated? The fact that it shares the same sizing with other sweaters puzzles me. Based on the size chart, I'm a M but based on Instagram comments, I'm a S.

Same boat. I'm a size 38. I've been trying to get rid of store credit for awhile now and finally pulled the trigger on the cardigan only to see this. I ordered a medium because of the site's chart only to see on Insta that they recommend a medium for a size 42. I think I'm going to switch order to a small. Either that or cancel the order and wait for advice here.

 

[Fancy Pants]

I hate to keep retreading this but trying to figure out the shawl sizing. I wear a 44 in S&M. I just measured a Gap shawl collar I have in Large and the chest is basically 46" - it fits well without being too slim or too baggy. According to the size chart I would have to go with an XXL. Then the replies on IG seem to indicate that an XL would be fine. What is the consensus?

 

[Salad]

I hate to keep retreading this but trying to figure out the shawl sizing. I wear a 44 in S&M. I just measured a Gap shawl collar I have in Large and the chest is basically 46" - it fits well without being too slim or too baggy. According to the size chart I would have to go with an XXL. Then the replies on IG seem to indicate that an XL would be fine. What is the consensus?

There is no consensus, lol. No one has it so IG sizing is probably the best bet, unfortunately.

 

[marker2037]

Thanks, I read your comments with interest.

Just to clarify, from what I read it sounds like you sized up for the coat, is that correct?

However, the S&M website is saying stick to your normal SC size.

Am I missing something, or has the cut and size changed??

Correct, I am a 42R jacket/suit and sized up to the 44 for the Polo coat. This is last year's model btw, but the cut of these has not changed for this year so sizing is the same.

The Outerwear is based on the contemporary block. For me, I have found that if you are in between sizes (like me, I am about 35" or so, and 36 works well), or on the slim side of the spectrum that the same size "should" work well. However, if you are a solid size (say 40" chest and 40 suit jacket size) and/or contemporary fit you should size up. However, like caktaylor said, all bodies are different.

I would say this is good advice. I'm a solid 42R contemporary with no body adjustments needed in the jacket or trouser waist, so I sized up. If I was a slim 42R or in between sizes at a 41" chest with a smaller waist I would consider getting a 42 polo coat instead.

Using size charts is a good idea but unfortunately Spier has a history of either not updating them or making mistakes. I hope the charts for the current items are both up to date and correct but if past is any indicator, best advice will come from those who buy and give the rest of us their take on sizing, fit and quality. Sadly, Rick's been away from this thread (though active on IG), otherwise he would confirm or clarify certain things. Rick, you coming back, man? @spiermackay

My 44 coat is spot on the measurements listed in the size chart so I think the charts for the polo coats are at least accurate.

Looking for some fit feedback on a 38R Contemporary, particularly the length. I’ve purchased a few items in this size and they overall fit me well, but I’m beginning to think the length of the 38R may be a little short on me. I’m about 5’11” or 11.5.” The jacket just barely covers my butt, and sometimes appears a little short in the front. I’m kind of on the fence. The 38L is only an extra 1.5 inches or so in length, but I’m wondering if that will be too much extra length. I do have fairly large hips, which may contribute to it looking short.

View attachment 1472885 View attachment 1472886 View attachment 1472887

Follow up question: does this shirt look too short (or alternatively is too much cuff showing)? I find with the first shirt it goes too far down my palm.
View attachment 1472993 View attachment 1472994

I would definitely suggest you to get a 38L and not shorten the sleeves so much. The shirts all fit you fine, it's the jacket sleeves that are too short.