Unfunded Liabilities: a/k/a The Cloth Thread

TheFoo · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by RSS

Not that you asked... but I definitely like. Bolder checks are my preference ... particularly during fall and winter. After a while, the ordinary just doesn't do it anymore ... it's simply another facet of mass production.

I agree with your preference for bolder patterns--certainly for odd jackets. But I am less concerned about the boldness, and more concerned about the particular color scheme. I have a little trouble imagining it with blue shirts (a must), and I happen to hate purple.

Originally Posted by yachtie

However, if you get it, you will be forever barred from making comments about anything I post.

Well, you already ignore my comments, so I've got nothing to lose!

yachtie · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by mafoofan

Well, you already ignore my comments, so I've got nothing to lose!
Oh, come on! Dismiss is not the same as ignore.

DocHolliday · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by RSS

A good number of posters aren't mafoofan. And in this case ... I'd say a good number of posters are ... quite frankly ... gutless. The coat is a steal ... as long as it fits.

But Doc, given that you are colorblind (the reason I've switched to gray) and find those colors perplexing, I exclude you from those covered by that comment.

I think your point about most posters not being Mafoo is a good one, but perhaps not solely in the way you intended. Does a guy who buys five pairs of the same shoes, who wants everything to be interchangeable, really want such a distinctive coat that can be worn only with a limited palate? Maybe he does (and only he can decide), but it seems at odds with his previously expressed desires.

I have a sportcoat in a deep red with a hint of purple -- call it wine/eggplant/aubergine -- and I enjoy it for occasional wear. But the limited utility means I'm not going to yank it out of the closet in the morning and throw it on with anything. It takes deliberation, and, when worn, it calls attention to itself, as I suspect this cloth will. Both those characteristics I thought Mafoo was trying to avoid.

I'm all for Mafoo branching out, but from what I've seen of his existing sportcoats, I suspect there are other avenues that would produce garments he would find more wearable and satisfying. Or maybe I'm reading him wrong.

chorse123 · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by yachtie

It makes me think of the circus. Just not loving the colors.

Film Noir Buff · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by chorse123

It makes me think of the circus. Just not loving the colors.

RSS · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by DocHolliday

Does a guy who buys five pairs of the same shoes, who wants everything to be interchangeable, really want such a distinctive coat that can be worn only with a limited palate?

Probably not.

Originally Posted by DocHolliday

Does a guy who buys five pairs of the same shoes, who wants everything to be interchangeable....

...it seems at odds with his previously expressed desires.

...from what I've seen of his existing sportcoats, I suspect there are other avenues that would produce garments he would find more wearable and satisfying.

Being here on a regular basis obviously has its advantages ... insight. If all this is true ... his purchase was a poor choice.

Too bad ... that's a great color combination for someone who has what it takes to wear it.

Film Noir Buff · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by RSS

Probably not. Being here on a regular basis obviously has it's advantages ... insight. If all this is true ... his purchase was a poor choice. Too bad ... that's a great color combination for someone who has what it takes to wear it.
Someone who has what it takes to wear it would hardly need to seek pre approval on the boards. I feel like I should do a one shot sale of all the fabrics I own and realize I will never get made up.

edmorel · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Film Noir Buff

.

I feel like I should do a one shot sale of all the fabrics I own and realize I will never get made up.

Jobber fabrics, how middle class.

TheFoo · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Film Noir Buff

Someone who has what it takes to wear it would hardly need to seek pre approval on the boards.

This is bullshit. Sharing pictures and discussing ideas isn't the same as seeking 'pre-approval'. You can pretend all you want that it is, but that would only make your participation here and the existence of your own forum all the more confounding.

Mildly Consumptive · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by edmorel

Jobber fabrics, how middle class.

Worse than middle class.

Mildly Consumptive · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by DocHolliday

I think your point about most posters not being Mafoo is a good one, but perhaps not solely in the way you intended. Does a guy who buys five pairs of the same shoes, who wants everything to be interchangeable, really want such a distinctive coat that can be worn only with a limited palate? Maybe he does (and only he can decide), but it seems at odds with his previously expressed desires.

I have a sportcoat in a deep red with a hint of purple -- call it wine/eggplant/aubergine -- and I enjoy it for occasional wear. But the limited utility means I'm not going to yank it out of the closet in the morning and throw it on with anything. It takes deliberation, and, when worn, it calls attention to itself, as I suspect this cloth will. Both those characteristics I thought Mafoo was trying to avoid.

I'm all for Mafoo branching out, but from what I've seen of his existing sportcoats, I suspect there are other avenues that would produce garments he would find more wearable and satisfying. Or maybe I'm reading him wrong.

This is not a purple tweed. It is a brown gunclub (with a purple overcheck). The two are very different things. The first goes with few things, the second goes with everything.Corduroys, flannels, moleskins, whipcords. Everything.

Film Noir Buff · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by edmorel

Jobber fabrics, how middle class.
I'll probably just throw them out.

Mildly Consumptive · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Film Noir Buff

I'll probably just throw them out.

still worse than middle class.

Film Noir Buff · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Mildly Consumptive

Worse than middle class.
You mean, (gulp)...your class?

voxsartoria · Jul 13, 2009

Originally Posted by Mildly Consumptive

still worse than middle class.

The pattern that he seeks for that cloth is only $26.20.

- B

Unfunded Liabilities: a/k/a The Cloth Thread

THE FOO

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

Quality Seller!!

THE FOO

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Goon member

Classic Menswear Featured products

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

Love them, classic!

Occasionally, depending on the outfit

Prefer flat-front

Never wear them

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON: