SPIER & MACKAY - Official Affiliate Thread

[Stylewords]

I'm sorry to pile on this, but my last 6 MTO suits have all had significant issues - wrong buttons, wrong inseam lengths, missing details, wrong shoulder padding, etc. all have had to go back. Some full canvas are really half (I've even ignored some errors out of exasperation). Even after repeatedly asking them to check before mailing, that has fallen on deaf ears, and so they have all had to go back. Not sure why a quick QC check can't be done prior to mailing...

I'm not disputing this, but why didn't you give up after 2 or 3?

 

[Imperatores]

Can't say as I don't have the cable knits.

With respect to the merino sweaters, this year Ls measure exactly as specified, while last year Ls measure as M.
This is just my personal experience so interested if others noticed a similar thing.

I'd love to hear from others as well. Which specific merino sweaters did you get from the current season? I was planning on grabbing a few knit polos, but maybe I won't have to size up this time around.

 

[MrFingers]

I'd love to hear from others as well. Which specific merino sweaters did you get from the current season? I was planning on grabbing a few knit polos, but maybe I won't have to size up this time around.

I got the cream cable knit turtleneck and charcoal, black turtlenecks. Last year I sized up to L and it fits fine but it looks like a comfy look. This time I stayed “TTS” and it looks form fitting (not tight) which is good because I plan on wearing these under a sportcoat. I’d advise to stick to your true size if that’s the idea and size up if you want to layer casually

 

[Imperatores]

I got the cream cable knit turtleneck and charcoal, black turtlenecks. Last year I sized up to L and it fits fine but it looks like a comfy look. This time I stayed “TTS” and it looks form fitting (not tight) which is good because I plan on wearing these under a sportcoat. I’d advise to stick to your true size if that’s the idea and size up if you want to layer casually

You mean the regular merino turtlenecks in charcoal and black (not cable knit)? The cable knits have always fit well in my true size. I'm wondering about the regular merino crew- and V-necks, turtlenecks and knit polos. Form fitting but not tight sounds ideal.

 

[MrFingers]

You mean the regular merino turtlenecks in charcoal and black (not cable knit)? The cable knits have always fit well in my true size. I'm wondering about the regular merino crew- and V-necks, turtlenecks and knit polos. Form fitting but not tight sounds ideal.

If assume they all fit somewhat similar. If I were to get others I would stick to the same size. I’m curious about that chunky oatmeal one but not too sure, plus it’s a bit pricey

 

[Imperatores]

If assume they all fit somewhat similar. If I were to get others I would stick to the same size. I’m curious about that chunky oatmeal one but not too sure, plus it’s a bit pricey

This one? I'm curious about that one too. 30 % nylon seems like a lot, though.

 

[MrFingers]

This one? I'm curious about that one too. 30 % nylon seems like a lot, though.

No sorry, this one: https://www.spierandmackay.com/product/stone-marled-pt2101-mrl-ttn-fw22

Only thing stopping me is that it looks a bit busy for a sweater. Not sure i would be able to layer it under a sportcoat

 

[Imperatores]

No sorry, this one: https://www.spierandmackay.com/product/stone-marled-pt2101-mrl-ttn-fw22

Only thing stopping me is that it looks a bit busy for a sweater. Not sure i would be able to layer it under a sportcoat

Not sure how I feel about that one, to be honest. It probably looks better in person, but there's something a bit too "ordinary" about it somehow. Almost looks a bit mall brand, if that's not too harsh. I definitely wouldn't wear it under a sportcoat myself. Seems more at home under casual outerwear or just worn on its own. I'm more interested in the English rib turtlenecks as an alternative to the cable knits myself. Limited color options though.

 

[1st Step]

Hell, I'd Do A Drive Thru In This, Dinner In The SUV, This Is Sweet...

 

[Shawl Lapel]

Do you have any pics of it closed and without the backpack? It looks surprisingly fitted if that is indeed your SC size. The chart makes them seem huge. How's sleeve width and armhole height?

It's a fitted cut. I'm a 40R and M was too big on me. The S is a perfect fit without the liner.

I wouldn't say it's super fitted, as in I'm pretty sure I could layer up and/or gain a few pounds and still be able to zip it, but it's not a really baggy coat either. Room through the chest is good and while the armholes aren't high you can move around without it pulling. Sleeve width is comfortable, can easily layer up and still flex your arms. If every season is bulking season the sleeves might not be so generous.

EDIT: Threw it on over a sportcoat today and the sleeve taper down towards your wrists isn't really conducive to fitting a sportcoat under the jacket. Sweaters are fine though.

Spoiler: Pics

 

[Maximus Rex]

I'm not disputing this, but why didn't you give up after 2 or 3?

They were all ordered in the same-ish timeframe... I do like their cuts and fabrics, and after corrections they are mostly okay. However, I may give up on future MTO orders...

 

[Jlee80]

They were all ordered in the same-ish timeframe... I do like their cuts and fabrics, and after corrections they are mostly okay. However, I may give up on future MTO orders...

When did you place this order?

 

[Maximus Rex]

When did you place this order?

Spring/Summer of this past year. The last pieces are still being fixed, so the end was after Malik left.

 

[Jlee80]

Spring/Summer of this past year. The last pieces are still being fixed, so the end was after Malik left.

Yeah… some of your issues mirror some of mine, when Malik was there.

 

[iguana]

Any shorter guys have success with the field jackets? I'm 5'6 and idk if it would be something I could have a tailor shorten