Man-of-Mystery
Distinguished Member
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2009
- Messages
- 4,909
- Reaction score
- 2,772
You're entirely right about one of the aims of the book being to describe in detail (if not illustrate) the original style, and thereby alter the public perception that skinhead was all about boots and braces. You're also right about the scarcity of photos from the era - true we have uncovered some that show something other than boots and braces, but not an overwhelming amount. Maybe we have enough, though.
I know the Osprey books too. I have a lot of earlier ones focussing on the Roman era, many illustrated by the late Ron Embleton. But what we have is a lot of verbal/textual material, and that is primarily what the book is drawing on. It's not an attempt to make a skinhead Osprey, nor to reproduce the Nick Knight book, and it shouldn't be either of those IMHO.
There are two or three people who are either on this thread or aware of the project who have artistic talent. Providing illustrations for the book wouldn't be totally out of the reach of this talent, but it would be impossible in practical terms, I would say, for any of them to devote the time and effort needed. We all have other lives to lead - I know first hand how difficult it is to find time here and there to devote to the simple task of transcribing text from this thread and then organising it into potential chapters. Also, I don't think illustrations would ever totally satisfy everyone. I'm already resigned to the fact that the fiercest critics of whatever emerges as the final book will probably come from our own ranks, and that's probably as it should be.
Hiring an illustrator would be prohibitively expensive. I recently engaged a semi-professional illustrator to make a simple design for a book cover. She charged me the equivalent of £50. That was cheap. Inflate that to professional rates, and then multiply that by the number of illustrations we would need for anything like the Nick Knight book or an Osprey edition, and we are talking about a considerable outlay, and one we will not get back, even if we try to flog off pints..
As long as this is something being run from the ground upwards, I'm afraid we have to forget a product with that level of illustration.
....
BUT - this is a long shot - how would you like me to turn this argument totally on its head, write to Osprey on my agency-headed paper and ask them if they would like to take over the whole project and produce a skinhead book based on our words and descriptions? It's a thought. They're likely to tell me to bugger off, but.. what do you think?
The reason I posed this question was that I recall the (fairly) recent discussion on illustrations for the book. I'm not quite sure of all of the stated objectives of the book, but I'm pretty sure one of them was to record or make people aware of the original skinhead styles. I suspect good quality photos showing the range of styles in different areas through the 'original' period will be difficult to obtain and illustrations may well be the answer. If that is the case then the quality of these drawings will be what define the book - they are the makings of the Nick Knight book, for example. I don't know if any of you are familiar with the 'Osprey' military history publications.I have bought some prior to trips to Arnhem, The Somme and Normandy for a bit of background reading. The illustrations really are first class and I suspect are the main reason why military history buffs and ... dare I say it..... re-enactors buy them. Once we are talking about the use of a professional illustrator, then costs will naturally rise but there could be a useful spin - off in that some of the prints could be sold - I would imagine there would be a minority market for something that is well done. Let's face it, if some of our number find themselves on the cover of a Japanese CD, then there is a demand for pictures of the style somewhere!
Naturally any illustrator is going to need considerable guidance to 'get it right' but this is probably the only opportunity there will be to do this.
You're entirely right about one of the aims of the book being to describe in detail (if not illustrate) the original style, and thereby alter the public perception that skinhead was all about boots and braces. You're also right about the scarcity of photos from the era - true we have uncovered some that show something other than boots and braces, but not an overwhelming amount. Maybe we have enough, though.
I know the Osprey books too. I have a lot of earlier ones focussing on the Roman era, many illustrated by the late Ron Embleton. But what we have is a lot of verbal/textual material, and that is primarily what the book is drawing on. It's not an attempt to make a skinhead Osprey, nor to reproduce the Nick Knight book, and it shouldn't be either of those IMHO.
There are two or three people who are either on this thread or aware of the project who have artistic talent. Providing illustrations for the book wouldn't be totally out of the reach of this talent, but it would be impossible in practical terms, I would say, for any of them to devote the time and effort needed. We all have other lives to lead - I know first hand how difficult it is to find time here and there to devote to the simple task of transcribing text from this thread and then organising it into potential chapters. Also, I don't think illustrations would ever totally satisfy everyone. I'm already resigned to the fact that the fiercest critics of whatever emerges as the final book will probably come from our own ranks, and that's probably as it should be.
Hiring an illustrator would be prohibitively expensive. I recently engaged a semi-professional illustrator to make a simple design for a book cover. She charged me the equivalent of £50. That was cheap. Inflate that to professional rates, and then multiply that by the number of illustrations we would need for anything like the Nick Knight book or an Osprey edition, and we are talking about a considerable outlay, and one we will not get back, even if we try to flog off pints..
As long as this is something being run from the ground upwards, I'm afraid we have to forget a product with that level of illustration.
....
BUT - this is a long shot - how would you like me to turn this argument totally on its head, write to Osprey on my agency-headed paper and ask them if they would like to take over the whole project and produce a skinhead book based on our words and descriptions? It's a thought. They're likely to tell me to bugger off, but.. what do you think?