GQGeek - what do you think of Chez L'Epicier? We had a really awesome dinner there last year but it seems like it's not everyone's cup of tea
I have not been to that one. On the montreal foodie forums it doesn't really come up that often so it's never been on my list of places that I absolutely have to try (with my limited budget). Maybe we're just spoiled since there are a plethora of very good restaurants in the city spanning the entire price spectrum.
Where else did you eat? I'd be interested to hear comparisons with NY since i've never eaten at any of the really famous places there. Almost all of the high-end dining i've done has been in montreal.
I'm actually dying to eat at a Keller restaurant since Keller has probably been the biggest influence on my own approach to cooking.