Don't sweat it too much... the Laphroaig 18 was my "base" drink for years so I had first row seats to the demise of what used to be a great dram which slowly lost its complexity, balance and depth of flavour. The labels also (IMHO) looked worse every iteration; more modern and international, I guess, just like the taste. It's not *bad* but is it worth the premium today?I've only ever had the 18 once, and have been on a hunt for a bottle ever since. It seems now that the 18 has (at least temporarily) been phased out for a 16.
This is not just Laphroaig of course, I think the Japanese whiskies were the worst affected by their own hype, with all the base ones moving from 12yo to NAS and becoming harsher and again, less long in the mouth and balanced.
I don't know if there is a good comparison. Perhaps between 1960s muscle cars and their modern equivalent.