Often under appreciated, but I love this shoe. Finally bought it. I own the natural one as well but sized down for this one and the fit is much better. It's the McTavish in Cognac and it goes great with my Dad jeans. Fits in with the "Go Bears" crowd that I'll be hanging with during tonights game unlike some of my other shoes... Size 8D. I am normally 8.5 to 9D depending on last/maker. It's got a great rough look to the leather but also some sheen that can be adjusting as desired via polish techniques.