The Official Wine Thread

tattersall · Oct 11, 2010

Originally Posted by Axelman 17

Some wine damage from a recent trip to Provence. Thanks for all the great vineyard/wine recs

Great choices - especially the Domaines Tempier and Pallieres - two of my favorites!

Piobaire · Oct 11, 2010

06 Stefania Uvas Creek Cab. Sauv.

vvoc · Oct 12, 2010

anyone have experience with pennywise wines? had a bottle of merlot earlier and drinking their pinot noir 2008 now...i like it, but i always have trouble properly rating wines. any tips?

kwilkinson · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by vvoc

anyone have experience with pennywise wines? had a bottle of merlot earlier and drinking their pinot noir 2008 now...i like it, but i always have trouble properly rating wines. any tips?

Here is how I rate wine:

Would not drink again.
Would drink again.
Would go out of my way to find another bottle.
Would kill to find another bottle.

That's all I really need. Numbers are lame and overrated.

vvoc · Oct 12, 2010

efficient system. i approve.

in that case i rate the pennywise pinot noir 2008 as i would drink again.

coolpapa · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by kwilkinson

Here is how I rate wine:

Would not drink again.
Would drink again.
Would go out of my way to find another bottle.
Would kill to find another bottle.

That's all I really need. Numbers are lame and overrated.

Your system is slightly more elaborate than mine, but I like it.

Piobaire · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by kwilkinson

Here is how I rate wine:

Would not drink again.
Would drink again.
Would go out of my way to find another bottle.
Would kill to find another bottle.

That's all I really need. Numbers are lame and overrated.

I give this post a 6/10.

ama · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by Piobaire

I give this post a 6/10.
I use a star system. Your post, for example, earns one star as per your average.

Piobaire · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by ama

I use a star system. Your post, for example, earns one star as per your average.

0/10.

ama · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by Piobaire

0/10.

zinnnnggggg

(two stars for that one btw, way to up your game!)

foodguy · Oct 12, 2010

some of you had expressed interest in the wines of Didier Dagueneau and in a story I'd mentioned several months ago. It has finally seen the light of day.

Mark from Plano · Oct 12, 2010

I finally bought a bottle of Merry Edwards SB (forget the year) at a restaurant the other night. WOW! At $30ish/bottle (substantially more than that at the restaurant), there has to be a reason why I'm not buying this by the case, but I can't really think what it might be. I gotta get me more of this. It just became my favorite white wine.

foodguy · Oct 12, 2010

me not so much. i really like her pinots, but i'm just not a big fan of so much oak on sb. it's like it's dressing up and trying to be a chardonnay (although, actually, i prefer less oak on chardonnays, too). these sentiments no doubt put me outside the wine mainstream, so feel free to ignore.

Manton · Oct 12, 2010

Has anyone had Didier post-Didier? Still as good?

Piobaire · Oct 12, 2010

Originally Posted by Mark from Plano

I finally bought a bottle of Merry Edwards SB (forget the year) at a restaurant the other night. WOW! At $30ish/bottle (substantially more than that at the restaurant), there has to be a reason why I'm not buying this by the case, but I can't really think what it might be. I gotta get me more of this. It just became my favorite white wine.

Originally Posted by foodguy

me not so much. i really like her pinots, but i'm just not a big fan of so much oak on sb. it's like it's dressing up and trying to be a chardonnay (although, actually, i prefer less oak on chardonnays, too). these sentiments no doubt put me outside the wine mainstream, so feel free to ignore.

This was a topic of discussion elsewhere. I don't find the oak that strong and I'm not an "oak bomb" guy by any means. In fact, I dislike oak bomb Chards. It seems some folks find the oak just right and not heavy and (a few) others feel it is over oaked. Something about that wine that seems to make the oak pop for a few folks.

The Official Wine Thread

Distinguished Member

Not left of center?

Senior Member

Having a Ball

Senior Member

Distinguished Member

Not left of center?

Distinguished Member

Not left of center?

Distinguished Member

Distinguished Member

Stylish Dinosaur

Distinguished Member

RINO

Not left of center?

FEATURED PRODUCTS

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

Definitely full canvas only

Half canvas is fine

Really don't care

Depends on fabric

Depends on price

Forum Sponsors

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON: