Carmina Shoes - Definitive Thread (reviews, advice, sizing, etc...) - official thread.

[jet-stream]

These are Simpsons in 10E, in marron calf. They seem duplicative, because they are, but medallion Adelaides are a weakness for me and I couldn't pass on the price. The fit is spectacular.

This was yesterday and their inaugural wear, so of course it rained. A lot.

I'm thinking of dying these to a more merlot/burgundy color, which would increase their utility in my wardrobe. Any thoughts? Is that heresy?

 

[eyeheartny]

These are Simpsons in 10E, in marron calf. They seem duplicative, because they are, but medallion Adelaides are a weakness for me and I couldn't pass on the price. The fit is spectacular.

This was yesterday and their inaugural wear, so of course it rained. A lot.

View attachment 853628

I'm thinking of dying these to a more merlot/burgundy color, which would increase their utility in my wardrobe. Any thoughts? Is that heresy?

Don’t dye them! Maybe just a little more antiquing around the toe and sides like the EG dark oak.

 

[ericgereghty]

Leave em. Is your fear that you have two near identical (or identical?) pairs? Nothing wrong with having two very similar pairs when they look that good.

 

[jet-stream]

Don’t dye them! Maybe just a little more antiquing around the toe and sides like the EG dark oak.

That is an interesting idea, I may play with that ...

 

[jet-stream]

Leave em. Is your fear that you have two near identical (or identical?) pairs? Nothing wrong with having two very similar pairs when they look that good.

Thank you. Not a fear exactly, more about how to get the most use out of them. Right now I'm not sure what would make me reach for calf over shell, except perhaps weather. However, burgundy works will pretty much all of my clothing, so it would quickly become a go-to travel shoe. The thought started because these have some (slightly) uneven finishing - that's what made them such a great deal. Much of it resolved with Renomat and polishing, and I can happily live with it, but I've already inceptioned myself. Perhaps I should install a topy and include them in my rotation of rain shoes ...

 

[Carmina]

That's a bold claim.. I'll take it upon myself to verify

Good afternoon, it looks like we have an opening date... 16th October. Keep checking our newsletters and instagram for more details..

 

[phsiao08]

Hi Carmina,

Were the prices on the Intertional Store raised?

Good afternoon, it looks like we have an opening date... 16th October. Keep checking our newsletters and instagram for more details..

 

[vmss]

It seems they increase the price for the Simpson,rain etc with extra 10 euro, but Inca lasted shoes are still the same. I wonder why the regulars are raised and not the Inca lasted shoes.

 

[chrfi]

I finally received a well fitting pair of the PTB's a few weeks ago and have been wearing them quite a lot. I like the last shape, and these are superbly made - at least as well as any of my Alden's or C&J's.

 

[sungmineyo]

Anyone interested in Rain last suede chukka GMTO?

5 eyelet, rubber sole in Polo or snuff suede

Been looking for 5 eyelet suede chukka for a long time but no makeup from retailers nowadays. If there are enough interests, I will organize this GMTO!

 

[Carmina]

Hi Carmina,

Were the prices on the Intertional Store raised?

We have slightly adjusted prices. International pricing has gone up for oxfords doubles monks.. and boots pricing has gone down.

US prices are unchanged.

Hopefully this will be more beneficial for the winter season.

 

[MrUnderwood]

@chrfi details of those please, i really like them.

 

[jet-stream]

Gentlemen, I'll be ordering an MTO from Carmina soon. I'd like a navy blue balmoral; my specific application will be primarily with suits in a business setting, but not an ultra-conservative one (not a presigious law firm or high finance). Thus, I have some flexibility and can break a couple of rules without consequence. I'm sure I will wear them more than in this setting, but that is the most restrictive requirement.

I'd like to gather opinions on a couple of items:

1. Shell or calf? Calf is more correct, but I still get a fair amount of creasing with the particular last I'll select. Navy shell just has a depth of color that is appealing, so I'm torn.

2. Whole cut or plain-toe Adelaide? Wholecuts are awesome but may be a bit aggressive. As noted, an Adelaide is somewhat more informal but that's not a limitation for me.

I'd greatly appreciate your inputs, and if you think I'm missing any considerations I am quite open to feedback. Thanks in advance!

 

[Manav Kapoor]

Gentlemen, I'll be ordering an MTO from Carmina soon. I'd like a navy blue balmoral; my specific application will be primarily with suits in a business setting, but not an ultra-conservative one (not a presigious law firm or high finance). Thus, I have some flexibility and can break a couple of rules without consequence. I'm sure I will wear them more than in this setting, but that is the most restrictive requirement.

I'd like to gather opinions on a couple of items:

1. Shell or calf? Calf is more correct, but I still get a fair amount of creasing with the particular last I'll select. Navy shell just has a depth of color that is appealing, so I'm torn.

2. Whole cut or plain-toe Adelaide? Wholecuts are awesome but may be a bit aggressive. As noted, an Adelaide is somewhat more informal but that's not a limitation for me.

I'd greatly appreciate your inputs, and if you think I'm missing any considerations I am quite open to feedback. Thanks in advance!

Carmina also does a Navy Museum Calf, so perhaps that could be a consideration as well? I have never seen it, but I imagine it is Ilcea Navy Museum and I have seen a few Meermin and Vass (below) makeups in it.

Also, is this the wholecut pattern?

 

[zanci]

Is there a wholecut boot possible to buy on the site now?

or just mto?