Ask A Question, Get An Answer... - Post All Quick Questions Here (Classic menswear)

[sparrow]



I'm trying to learn a little about fit. I've slimmed down recently and have been trying some slim-fitting shirts. To varying degrees, most of them seem to pull a little from the second-to-top button to about 2/3 down the shoulder. Here's the most exaggerated example that I have:

What aspect of the shirt (or of my body) causes this? Is it something that can be inexpensively tailored? Pictured is a Ralph Lauren slim fit.

Thanks in advance.

Too tight I think. Cut not good for u
Let's see what others also say about that

 

[SBear]

I'm trying to learn a little about fit. I've slimmed down recently and have been trying some slim-fitting shirts. To varying degrees, most of them seem to pull a little from the second-to-top button to about 2/3 down the shoulder. Here's the most exaggerated example that I have:



What aspect of the shirt (or of my body) causes this? Is it something that can be inexpensively tailored? Pictured is a Ralph Lauren slim fit.

Thanks in advance.

Looks to me like your shoulders are too broad for this shirt, which is causing the V wrinkle. Problem with many slim fit shirts is that the slimming is done primarily (or completely) by narrowing the entire torso (keeping more or less vertical sides). Many people who want a more shaped fit want a shirt that TAPERS more than standard (in a jacket we would call this a 'drop', as the difference between chest and waist measurements). The result is that when you find a shirt that fits the shoulders the waist is still too wide (can be corrected by a tailor) or that when you find a shirt that fits in the waist, the shoulders are too narrow (which really isn't reasonably fixable).

 

[J011yroger]



Looks to me like your shoulders are too broad for this shirt, which is causing the V wrinkle. Problem with many slim fit shirts is that the slimming is done primarily (or completely) by narrowing the entire torso (keeping more or less vertical sides). Many people who want a more shaped fit want a shirt that TAPERS more than standard (in a jacket we would call this a 'drop', as the difference between chest and waist measurements). The result is that when you find a shirt that fits the shoulders the waist is still too wide (can be corrected by a tailor) or that when you find a shirt that fits in the waist, the shoulders are too narrow (which really isn't reasonably fixable).

What is the approximate cost to have a shirt tapered? I have quite a few that are too blousey when tucked in, and I'm not sure if I should just buy slimmer ones, or bother having them altered.

J

 

[jimanchower]

Thanks SBear, that makes a lot of sense. You too, sparrow.

 

[sparrow]



What is the approximate cost to have a shirt tapered? I have quite a few that are too blousey when tucked in, and I'm not sure if I should just buy slimmer ones, or bother having them altered.

J

Try darts should be cheaper
It's a stitch that tapers

 

[J011yroger]

Thanks!

J

 

[Terpo]

If you get an MTM shirt is it a better idea to get darts made into the shirt by the tailor or have less fabric at the back? And if darts is the option, how do you specify the amount of cloth to taper?

 

[sparrow]

Mtm wouldn't have darts
Darts are for slimming. Rack items

 

[Terpo]

Mtm wouldn't have darts
Darts are for slimming. Rack items

OK, so that would mean I need to specify separate front and back measurements rather than the ordinary: chest, waist, bottom measurements I guess.

 

[sparrow]

I would ask your tailor what they need
It would be weird to have differ t front back

 

[JezeC]

some feedback?

 

[loarbmhs]

Overall, I think it looks pretty nice. Two minor quibbles:

1. I think I'd prefer the jacket sleeves just a bit longer.
2. Not sure about the buttons on the coat--seem a little big.

But again, solid effort overall!

 

[12345Michael54321]

I agree with loarbmhs; the jacket sleeves could stand to be just a little longer.

I don't agree with him with regard to the buttons. The jacket buttons don't seem freakishly large to me, although I accept that judging their precise size is difficult in a small picture. But in any case, it's a blazer. Blazer buttons are permitted - some might even argue, expected - to call more attention to themselves than are most other sport coat buttons, or certainly most suit coat buttons. I mean, they're routinely metallic and bear crests or other emblems, so clearly going unnoticed isn't the main objective.

As for the rest of it, while the jacket appears to be a more modern fit (I prefer a more traditional fit), it's certainly not freakishly short or tight, so good enough. The shirt looks okay, what little can be seen of it. The pants look a little more snug in the thigh than I'd prefer (but as I've already noted, I prefer more traditional fits). The color match between pants and jacket is okay.

Overall, not really an A+, but certainly a credible effort.

 

[jpjdavid83]

I'm really interested in purchasing my first pair of AE. I hope you guys can help me out with some of my questions.

1. Is the sizing chart in the AE website accurate? I understand that it will always be best if I go to an actual store but in my case that is not possible since AE is not available locally in my country (Philippines). Based on the chart my shoe size is a 9D.

2. I am currently looking at either the Strand or the Mcallister. Any inputs on which I should get first would be highly appreciated. Also since I am a size 9D do I need to size up/down based on these shoe models?

3. If I am going to buy second hand shoes, what are the things that I should look/check out for?

Thanks.

 

[HeywoodJablome]

I'm really interested in purchasing my first pair of AE. I hope you guys can help me out with some of my questions.

1. Is the sizing chart in the AE website accurate? I understand that it will always be best if I go to an actual store but in my case that is not possible since AE is not available locally in my country (Philippines). Based on the chart my shoe size is a 9D.

2. I am currently looking at either the Strand or the Mcallister. Any inputs on which I should get first would be highly appreciated. Also since I am a size 9D do I need to size up/down based on these shoe models?

3. If I am going to buy second hand shoes, what are the things that I should look/check out for?

Thanks.

1. Size chart is hard to use... I'd go one size down from your sneaker size. I wear a 7 in Nikes, and a 6 in AE. The size chart might be good for determining the width.
2. Get Walnut Strands, hands down the best shoe they make - they'll change your life. The Strand last is "longer" than some of their other ones I think, but in reality, if you're new AE, you won't notice (I didn't). See #1 regarding sizing.
3. Make sure there's no cracks in the upper, and that the soles aren't too worn down.

Also, spend some time on the AE appreciation thread - it's chock full of info.