Sperry or Rockport?

[Twotone]

On sale today @ Macy's for $40/pair. I could not decide in the store, so I picked up a pair of each. To be worn with jeans, Dockers and possibly blue seersucker. I do not need two pair of similar shoes.

Which is the keeper and which to return?

Thanks in advance!

Twotone (no reference to shoe preference)

Solid blue Rockport

Dark/light blue Sperry

 

[dfagdfsh]

neither

 

[Jokerman]

Originally Posted by Teger

neither

Agreed. Although if I had to choose one it would be sperry as it is the original boat shoe.

 

[greekonomist]

cake or death?

 

[OxWing]

If you're set on owning one of those two pair, I like the Rockports, but I also tend to be pretty conservative in color choices. Quality should be similar between the two pairs. You should be able to find a pair of solid navy Sperry's online for like $60-70, and that's what I'd do.

 

[phillyesq]

Originally Posted by OxWing

If you're set on owning one of those two pair, I like the Rockports, but I also tend to be pretty conservative in color choices. Quality should be similar between the two pairs. You should be able to find a pair of solid navy Sperry's online for like $60-70, and that's what I'd do.

+1

I got a pair of Sperry's earlier this summer, and I paid about $40. I used shoebuy, and combined 20% off with bing.com cashback.

I love boat shoes, and I like navy, but I don't find either of these appealing.

 

[litho]

Sperry!

 

[Arcanaville]

the yellow stripe really ruins the first ones for me... im agreeing with the others and saying buy some solid navy sperrys

 

[Chips]

Originally Posted by Arcanaville

the yellow stripe really ruins the first ones for me... im agreeing with the others and saying buy some solid navy sperrys

+1