Twill Jacket - J.Crew or Rugby?

[Preparatory]

Hi, Need some opionions on which of these two jackets I should purchase. I think the Rugby one looks slightly better but my main concern is regarding sizing and fitting. I prefer a trimmer fitting and the J.Crew jacket I think has a trimmer fit than the Rugby one. Is the sizing for Rugby the same as for Polo? Rugby:

J.Crew:

 

[Preparatory]

Also I would like to hear what you have got to say about thq quality of Rugby stuff?

 

[Antonio Centeno]

Why not buy the Rugby and have it adjusted by a local tailor?

 

[Ianiceman]

I in for a cotton chino or poplin style suit for the summer. Tried on the jacket in J Crew. Couldn't put my finger on it but the fit was all off to me. For one thing dreaded shoulder divots but also the sleeves seemed ridiculously narrow and constricting. Other stuff I couldn't really describe but I passed.

 

[Preparatory]

Originally Posted by Antonio Centeno

Why not buy the Rugby and have it adjusted by a local tailor?

Yea, I could do that. Still not sure about rugby sizing. I have a Small in RL Polo. Same thing for Rugby, anyone who knows... please?

 

[Saturdays]

I have a Small Navy Sack Jacket from Rugby, it fits great I'm a 36 when it comes to suiting. Everything is slimmer compared to Polo RL.
Quality is pretty good just Cotton wrinkles a lot and needs to be ironed, but it is more breathable.