The Overcoat Thread

[FlyingHorker]

No, there are no specific features I desire. It is more about the overall look. Thanks for the link but "a little" over my budget.

Camel Wool Polo Coat

100% Wool. Made in Italy

www.drakes.com

Could ask about the sizing in the Drake's thread if it interests you.

 

[mebiuspower]

^Both are quite overpriced for both 100% cashmere and 100% wool...

 

[FlyingHorker]

^Both are quite overpriced for both 100% cashmere and 100% wool...

I agree.

I'd rather just go to my local bespoke tailor, but I don't know if he has that option.

 

[dieworkwear]

I've been wearing a Drake's Balmacaan and Kaptain Sunshine traveler coat the most. They don't look like the alpaca coat in that photo, but they are full, long coats that have a similar vibe.

 

[comrade]

Just found this vintage Chipp Ivy Alpaca- lined double-breasted tweed
on eBay. Perfect for the next Polar Vortex!

TRAD GRAIL vtg CHIPP New Haven Herringbone Tweed ALPACA PILE Overcoat USA 42 | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for TRAD GRAIL vtg CHIPP New Haven Herringbone Tweed ALPACA PILE Overcoat USA 42 at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!

www.ebay.com

 

[Salad]

Just got this coat and was thinking of shortening the hem to about the knee. Probably 3 or 4 inches. Now I'm thinking of just keeping it as is.
What do you guys think? Hem it or nah? Ignore penor belt action in last pick.

 

[dieworkwear]

Just got this coat and was thinking of shortening the hem to about the knee. Probably 3 or 4 inches. Now I'm thinking of just keeping it as is.
What do you guys think? Hem it or nah? Ignore penor belt action in last pick.

View attachment 1727916

View attachment 1727913


View attachment 1727911

I think I could go either way. I like the longer cut on you, but don't think shortening it would necessarily be a mistake. Above the knee and I think it would lose some of its charm.

If I were you, I would wear the longer cut for a while and make a decision next winter. You can always shorten a coat but you can't lengthen it.

 

[Despos]

Proportions look good as it is. You can pin the coat shorter yourself and get a visual. You don’t need a tailor. Will help you decide. Stand as far back from the mirror as you can to get perspective.
If you shorten the coat you may want to trim/take in the skirt at the hem. May look flared out and exaggerate an A line silhouette when shortened. Proportions change and you want to maintain a balance of girth and length.

 

[Salad]

^Yeah, that's about where I'm at right now. I actually tried to get a consult from Advanced Euro in Berkeley yesterday to see what he thought but when I got there the tailor, I forget his name, wasn't there. I'm concerned about the vent looking funny if too much length is taken off.
I think I'll keep as is for now but I do think a little shorter would be good. Nothing above the knee, though.

 

[FlyingHorker]

My belted bal coat initially hit on my lower calf and I disliked it right away, I felt self conscious about dragging it along the ground whenever I sat down.

I had it shortened to my upper calf area and that's where I prefer it. Still maintains the dramatic effect of a longer overcoat, keeps my legs warm, and looks balanced.

 

[Despos]

Guessing 2” shorter is the sweet spot. Shorter but not too short. Pin it up and see.
i like the current length but it is also a sense of how it feels to you and not just looks.

 

[comrade]

Leave it as it is. It looks great on you.

 

[bicycleradical]

Just got this coat and was thinking of shortening the hem to about the knee. Probably 3 or 4 inches. Now I'm thinking of just keeping it as is.
What do you guys think? Hem it or nah? Ignore penor belt action in last pick.

View attachment 1727916

View attachment 1727913


View attachment 1727911

This is a very nice coat, made from a lovely fabric, and fits very well. I say leave it.

 

[goalaso]

Just got this coat and was thinking of shortening the hem to about the knee. Probably 3 or 4 inches. Now I'm thinking of just keeping it as is.
What do you guys think? Hem it or nah? Ignore penor belt action in last pick.

View attachment 1727916

View attachment 1727913


View attachment 1727911

What coat is this?

 

[milktoast]

Must admit that the Die, Workwear and Menswear Musings blogs helped me appreciate balmacaans more. They have presence, without being visually overbearing. An ideal addition to my wardrobe for the brutal Northeast Winters.
Nonetheless, this obviously comes at a cost and I'm now searching for one that won't break the bank. Really digging Spier & MacKay's charcoal herringbone balmacaan from last year -- if anyone is willing to part with one in a 36R, please contact me. Otherwise my hunt continues! Will also be keeping an eye on this thread for inspiration on other contenders.