We have a thread about underappreciated, why not about over? Here's a short list: Little Miss Sunshine - Meanders, boring, predictable, cutesy but not cute 300 - Douchebag Film The Dark Night - Average Action Flick Sin City - WTF did I just watch? Juno - Highly unbelievable, but Ellen Page is a good actor Knocked Up - Total rubbish... Completely unbelievable I'm also tempted to say Taxi Driver, but I won't as De Niro is one of my favorite actors. I've seen it once and it didn't do it for me. Perhaps I missed the point of it or it's just the genre. But, then again, I didn't enjoy Citizen Kane the first time I saw it. The second time I watched it (a few months later) I loved it and realized why people say it is one of the best movies ever made.