Brady vs. Manning: The Final Battle

[edinatlanta]

Originally Posted by guster

Thanks Junk

buurn

 

[Douglas]

Well, I think this debate, at least for StyleForum purposes, has just been settled. Manning wins, on account of this:

http://www.bostonherald.com/track/in...99826&srvc=rss

 

[soxpats]

Originally Posted by Douglas

Well, I think this debate, at least for StyleForum purposes, has just been settled. Manning wins, on account of this: http://www.bostonherald.com/track/in...99826&srvc=rss
That's funny considering Manning will do anything that gets him extra money. CUT THAT MEAT! Can't you come up with something a little better then that. 9-10 or 14-4, 3 SB wins vs 1 SB win kind of says it all.

 

[LawrenceMD]

Originally Posted by soxpats

That's funny considering Manning will do anything that gets him extra money. CUT THAT MEAT! Can't you come up with something a little better then that. 9-10 or 14-4, 3 SB wins vs 1 SB win kind of says it all.

dude i'm the hugest Pats fan evar... but SONY Flatscreen TV>pair of uggs

plus well manning is flat out funnier than brady.

that being said. playoff record comparison BRADY dry anal rapes manning.

 

[Ambulance Chaser]

Can we all agree that Manning is better at turning a bad team into a good team and that Brady is better at turning a great team into a championship team?

 

[StephenHero]

End this.

 

[LawrenceMD]

Originally Posted by StephenHero

End this.

 

[montecristo#4]

Originally Posted by Ambulance Chaser

Can we all agree that Manning is better at turning a bad team into a good team and that Brady is better at turning a great team into a championship team?

No.

5-11 2000 Patriots team says hi.

 

[phreak]

Originally Posted by montecristo#4

No.

5-11 2000 Patriots team says hi.

Haha so does Brady's 86 rating in 2001 on 411 attempts. But yea you're probably right, Brady deserves more credit that Belichick for that turnaround.

 

[clubbyjones]

Originally Posted by Douglas

Well, I think this debate, at least for StyleForum purposes, has just been settled. Manning wins, on account of this: http://www.bostonherald.com/track/in...99826&srvc=rss

I'd take Uggs over the Oreo challenge. Or the Chunky Soup ads. The only good commercial Peyton ever did was the "This is Sportscenter" one where him an Eli act like bickering brothers during a tour. edit: Link to vid

 

[whiteslashasian]

Originally Posted by clubbyjones

I'd take Uggs over the Oreo challenge. Or the Chunky Soup ads.

The only good commercial Peyton ever did was the "This is Sportscenter" one where him an Eli act like bickering brothers during a tour.

edit: Link to vid



Actually, I'd probably take the DSRL Oreo commercials over Uggs (some of them got a chuckle out of me).

Peyton is completely exonerated for any and all questionable commercials by his exceptional turn as a SNL host; legendary.

 

[montecristo#4]

Originally Posted by phreak

Haha so does Brady's 86 rating in 2001 on 411 attempts. But yea you're probably right, Brady deserves more credit that Belichick for that turnaround.

This 86 passer rating was good for 6th in the league, moron. Not only that, it beat Manning's.

1. Kurt Warner*+ · STL 101.4
2. Rich Gannon* · OAK 95.5
3. Jeff Garcia* · SFO 94.8
4. Brett Favre* · GNB 94.1
5. Steve McNair · TEN 90.2
6. Tom Brady* · NWE 86.5
7. Donovan McNabb* · PHI 84.3
8. Mark Brunell · JAX 84.1
Chris Chandler · ATL 84.1
Peyton Manning · IND 84.1

Also funny how the team started the season 0-2 under Bledsoe, losing to the Jets and the Bungles. But then suddenly went 14-3 the rest of the way under Brady to win the Super Bowl.

Yeah, that had nothing to do with Brady.

 

[phreak]

Dude, don't get upset. Really it's not that big of a deal

Just for the record though, that is one of 3 seasons where Brady had a better rating. That is out of 10. You caught Peyton on a down year and Brady, well, just an average year.

Edit*

And yes, I'm ready for this thread to die

 

[soxpats]

Originally Posted by phreak

Dude, don't get upset. Really it's not that big of a deal

Just for the record though, that is one of 3 seasons where Brady had a better rating. That is out of 10. You caught Peyton on a down year and Brady, well, just an average year.

Edit*

And yes, I'm ready for this thread to die

But you won't let it. Kinda the guy that has to have the last word. The only number that matters in the end is Brady 3 and Manning 1. Hell I'll give you both Manning's and its still 3-2. It is what it is people. This thread won't die because Manning ball washers keep coming back to try and convince the real Football people that he's a better QB. Actually when it is all said and done we will really know and yes that will still be Brady.

 

[phreak]

By 'real Football people' (capital F, ok Jaws) you are speaking about youself I take it? You are a dedicated lifelong Pats fan who has openly stated dislike for the Colts, so you really have no credibility in the debate. Some people can be partisan while still being intelligent, obviously you cannot. I'm a Colts fan but only since I started liking football. I was raised on a heavy dose of Cowboys.

And no, I am not trying to get the last word. I really don't give a ****. In fact, I have said a few times in this very thread about how it's nearly impossible to accurately compare these two players.