The model number is the same so they should be the same boot. The only difference would be the TSM branding on the innards.
For reference, I tried on a pair of the TSM 4060 4 months ago when I swung by the shop. I only recently could budget the 4060 and I got them from Madison. They are identical boots. So while this is not an apples to apples comparison, the only difference is the color of dye. I could not see any reason that the black should be any different.
Someone with far more Alden knowledge may chime in and tell us otherwise but I'd venture to say they are the same boot.
Oh yeah, almost forgot to mention, buy them! You will not be disappointed.
Your experience is really helpful to me, i really appreciate your help.
Now i have the 4065 and 4070 colour 8 version in my collection. And the naval boot will be arrive after 6months:)
I have to admit that i am addict to cap toe rather than other make up.