I think it's just an awful, ill-fitting look and more suited to people hiding excess weight problems. Such baggy and formless coats will never look as good on the average man as sharp and form-fitting overcoats. The models look like kids in adults clothing, ugh.I know you like that silhouette, and maybe it's just a matter of body type (I'm a 5'8", 160#) – but I really just look like a human tepee in coats like that.