Shoe advice...

[mymil]

Not to pick on you specifically, but I see this advice a lot and I wonder, does having two pairs make each pair last MORE than twice as long? If the idea that owning more than one pair of shoes because they'll last longer is just based on the fact that you're only wearing each half as often, then that isn't really something notable.

I think it does, because it means you can allow the interior of the shoe to dry between wearings. Otherwise your foot moisture will be a permanent feature of the inside of your shoes. So it would help the interior of the shoe last longer. I don't see any reason why it would help any of the exterior to last longer.

 

[frenchji]

Otherwise your foot moisture will be a permanent feature of the inside of your shoes.

How much do your feet sweat? I have a hard time believing that any moisture in your shoes wouldn't dry completely by the next day you put them on. Maybe I don't sweat as much as you or the average person then or something.

 

[mcbrown]



I think it does, because it means you can allow the interior of the shoe to dry between wearings. Otherwise your foot moisture will be a permanent feature of the inside of your shoes. So it would help the interior of the shoe last longer. I don't see any reason why it would help any of the exterior to last longer.

Along with proper care, rest will also help the upper last longer. In my pre-SF days I ran through my fair share of cheap dress shoes where the uppers started cracking long before the (synthetic) soles wore out, due to the abuse of every day wear.

How much do your feet sweat?  I have a hard time believing that any moisture in your shoes wouldn't dry completely by the next day you put them on.  Maybe I don't sweat as much as you or the average person then or something.

Lurk moar. Read shoe care thread.

 

[Ashlandleather]

I suggest you look at the Allen Edmonds Black Hills.
http://www.allenedmonds.com/aeonline/producti_SF2905_1_40000000001_-1
They look better in person than the website photo.
Chris

I'll second AE Black Hills in Chestnut or Black. They definitely look better in person and they are really comfortable.

 

[dapperdoctor]

How much do your feet sweat? I have a hard time believing that any moisture in your shoes wouldn't dry completely by the next day you put them on. Maybe I don't sweat as much as you or the average person then or something.

If you stay on this web site long enough, pretty soon you will own 75 pairs of shoes and this will not be a problem.

 

[mymil]

Along with proper care, rest will also help the upper last longer. In my pre-SF days I ran through my fair share of cheap dress shoes where the uppers started cracking long before the (synthetic) soles wore out, due to the abuse of every day wear.
Lurk moar. Read shoe care thread.

I'm not surprised crappy uppers deteriorated quickly (in terms of number of days worn). I'm curious whether you think it's more because they were crappy, because you didn't condition them regularly enough, or because you wore them multiple days in a row? It seems like the first two are the more likely culprits.

 

[mcbrown]



I'm not surprised crappy uppers deteriorated quickly (in terms of number of days worn). I'm curious whether you think it's more because they were crappy, because you didn't condition them regularly enough, or because you wore them multiple days in a row? It seems like the first two are the more likely culprits.

I actually think it's the third, for various reasons. Of course I recognize that my sample of... well, me... is hardly a scientific study. Anyway, here is my analysis of the other two possible factors:

1. Crappy leather: Possibly a contributor, but on the other hand I have a pair of fake leather Dr. Marten boots (don't ask) that were my primary bad weather shoe for about a decade, and with no upper care other than occasional wax polishing, the uppers have outlasted the soles. Granted these are synthetic, but I have a great deal of experience with synthetic leather shoes (again, don't ask) and in my experience fake leather is far more prone to cracking than real leather, not the other way around. Since these Dr. Marten's (a) were used disproportionately in bad conditions compared to my other shoes, (b) have soles in need of replacement (indicating that they have had considerable use over their life), and (c) still have not cracked, I conclude that some combination of care and rest has preserved them.

2. Insufficient conditioning: Possible, but eons ago I was a frequent traveler and made liberal use of the airport shoeshine stand. So my shoes didn't get the care they do now post-SF, but they received a frequent dose of cream polish of some variety. And it's true that my shoes lasted longer in my road warrior days than after, presumably because of the additional care, but I was still replacing them about every year.

 

[mymil]

But why would it take fewer successive days of flexing the vamp (i.e. wearing the shoes) than flexing the vamp only on alternate days? I just can't think of a good reason for it, because it's not as though the leather heals while it's resting.

 

[dddrees]

How much do your feet sweat? I have a hard time believing that any moisture in your shoes wouldn't dry completely by the next day you put them on. Maybe I don't sweat as much as you or the average person then or something.

You can go to almost any place where proper shoe care is discussed and they will all recomend making sure your shoe gets at least one day off between wearing for this very reason.

 

[mcbrown]



But why would it take fewer successive days of flexing the vamp (i.e. wearing the shoes) than flexing the vamp only on alternate days? I just can't think of a good reason for it, because it's not as though the leather heals while it's resting.

I'm not a scientist in the field of leather care. I can speculate as to reasons why this effect exists but I can't prove them to you to a reasonable statistical confidence. I'm happy to speculate if you wish, but I would suggest doing your own research with better experts than me.

 

[mymil]

^ Feel free to speculate, I have my salt ready.

 

[mcbrown]

Well, in that case...

When a shoe is on your foot, even if you are not walking, a couple of things are happening to it:

1) the shoe is at an elevated temperature
2) the shoe is absorbing moisture from your foot
3) even if you aren't walking, your foot is not completely still and is therefore subtly flexing the shoe throughout the day

When the shoe does not have adequate rest, the upper never completely discharged the moisture accumulated through the day. When the leather stays too moist day after day, the elevated temperature and constant motion damage the leather. Giving the leather 24-36 hours to rest allows the excess moisture to completely exit the shoe, and the next time you wear the show it will have the capacity to take a day's worth of wear and moisture better.

Of course it's not a hard line: your shoes won't just fall apart if you wear them 2 or 3 or 10 days in a row - when I travel on vacation I usually try to bring just one pair of shoes, and they live. But if done for months on end I fully believe it takes a noticeable toll.

 

[SirTristan]

I view walking in shoes equivalent to mileage on a car. A casual boot might be the best bet for everyday use. Chukka boots comes to mind but don't listen to me. I'm knew this part of the fashion world.