330CK
Affiliate Vendor
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2008
- Messages
- 3,352
- Reaction score
- 21,495
Okay, I can reply to this because I'm not going to address guns at all. Now I will discuss morality.
What you describe involves everyone believing the same thing. This mechanism you speak of relies on a wholly accepted morality.
Example: A Clockwork Orange. The protagonist, Alex, runs about ******, pillaging, and breaking every law possible. He is finally caught and has the chance to accept behavioral modification therapy in lieu of jail time. He is literally programmed like a computer and loses his free will. He is programmed to do what the government thinks is "right". He is conditioned to feel sick at the thought of doing something "wrong". This is similar to this device you speak of.
Problem is, people have different opinions. And that's great. It makes us humans. People should be free to choose what's right for themselves as long as it doesn't affect another person's same right.
No, making guns illegal would help everyone. Period. As others have said, it will never happen because there are just too many guns already out there (which hasn't swayed the drug legalization argument much, but that's another story--even though the bulk of illegal drugs haven't killed as many folks as legal ones). In an ideal world, a person should not have the right to decide what is right for them. A person should know, intuitively, what is right and what is wrong, and if they have difficulty making that distinction, then a mechanism should exist to prevent them from making decisions that are harmful to others. In short, your right to own a gun ends with my right to exist. The ability of anyone with a benjamin or two to own a gun threatens my right to exist, and that is wrong. I really don't think it gets much simpler than that, and that the criminal justice system has a means to punish those who interfere with my right to exist doesn't make me breathe once I've stopped.
Okay, I can reply to this because I'm not going to address guns at all. Now I will discuss morality.
What you describe involves everyone believing the same thing. This mechanism you speak of relies on a wholly accepted morality.
Example: A Clockwork Orange. The protagonist, Alex, runs about ******, pillaging, and breaking every law possible. He is finally caught and has the chance to accept behavioral modification therapy in lieu of jail time. He is literally programmed like a computer and loses his free will. He is programmed to do what the government thinks is "right". He is conditioned to feel sick at the thought of doing something "wrong". This is similar to this device you speak of.
Problem is, people have different opinions. And that's great. It makes us humans. People should be free to choose what's right for themselves as long as it doesn't affect another person's same right.