Patrick1053
Distinguished Member
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2020
- Messages
- 1,446
- Reaction score
- 2,227
Basically, by doing a strict comparison of construction, TLB beats Carmina. But if you are not so concerned about the finer details then Carmina has more leather options, more last options, more sole options, and more style options. So if there is a shoe from Carmina that TLB has an equivalent of, then I would go with TLB, but if you wanted a U- cap wingtip boot made with Blue, Green, and Natural Shell cordovan on a very casual rounded toe last with an Aspen sole made from hevea milk then you are gonna have to go with Carmina.Anyone own both these and some Carminas that can speak to their differences? Which should I go with? I'm honestly torn. Carmina has a lot more lasts though which is awesome
And yes, if you are in the US (like me), then you are gonna pay a higher mark up for those special Carmina's too.Yeah, it surely happens a lot between budget welted shoes and good midrange shoes. It's a bit like for bicycles, a road bike or mountainbike at €1,000 is way behind a bike at around €2,000 in all regards, while you have to pay much more for smaller differences going from that, the €2,000 bike is not that big of a difference compared to a €5,000 bike.
Regarding the second thing, of course, you have to like the style you’re going for. And, fit need to be good. I mean, a pair of Allen Edmonds can be a better purchase for you than both of the ones mentioned here, if you like their style much more and if you have a last that fits you much better from them.
I don't think everyone realises what a ridiculously good deal TLB and especially Artista is, and especially for people in the states. I mean, the RRP in Europe is great, a lot of bang for the buck, perhaps the best price-quality ratio available. And all lucky bastards over there have a very strong dollar now and can get it minus the 20-25% VAT, with free shipping, without having to pay any import dutys or taxes. It's bloody crazy!!
I would be stocking up on shitloads of Artistas if I were a US guy, even if there's no changes on the horizon, one never know, currencies can fluctuate to make it less favourable, some new large retailers in the states might not accept EU retailers selling without VAT, the $800 limit for tax free private imports might change (for me being a EU citizen, I can't understand why Trump nags over the presumable EU favourable situation when it comes to customs etc, when we private persons have to pay shitloads of customs and VAT etc for everything we bring from the US to Europe), etc.
Last edited: