Formality of Sack Suit vs Business Suit

Midnight Blue · Dec 12, 2007

I have noticed that Emily Post classifies the sack suit as being more formal than the business suit. I thought the the sack was just one of a number of silhouettes that could be used as a business suit. Is it in fact something more than that?

AldenPyle · Dec 12, 2007

Rule #1: Don't take sartorial advice from someone named Emily.

appolyon · Dec 12, 2007

^ +1

The 'sack' is a type of cut for a suit ...

Sator · Dec 12, 2007

Perhaps you are reading a different edition but this is what I found: http://www.bartleby.com/95/34.html "The business suit or three-piece sack is made or marred by its cut alone." That sentence implies she used the term "sack suit" as the American equivalent of the British "lounge suit".

Midnight Blue · Dec 12, 2007

Originally Posted by Sator

Perhaps you are reading a different edition but this is what I found:

http://www.bartleby.com/95/34.html

"The business suit or three-piece sack is made or marred by its cut alone."

That sentence implies she used the term "sack suit" as the American equivalent of the British "lounge suit".

Ah, perhaps she is using the terms interchangeably. The passage that confused me was from the 1955 edition:

"Merely to clear away much confusion: Semi-formal does not mean women in formal evening dresses and men in business suits. In communities where the tail coat is worn, semi-formal means dinner jackets (tuxedos) and simple evening dresses. In others where the dinner jacket is formal, semi-formal would mean men in dark sack suits and women in so-called cocktail dresses."

An incorrect illustration of a "sackcoat" in the 1997 edition showing what seems to be a shawl collar tuxedo didn't help either.

Thank for helping to clear this up.

Sator · Dec 12, 2007

The dinner jacket is, of course, also a type of lounge coat. The older British term in Victorian times was "dress lounge", although this term was superceded in the 19th century by the term "dinner jacket" (see Norah Waugh for the reference). All older American tailoring manuals only use the term "sack coat" to drescribe a lounge coat (just as they always say "cutaway" instead of the British "morning coat&quot

.

So perhaps the characterisation of the dinner jacket as a "sackcoat" is also intentional.

sidvar · Dec 12, 2007

I thought sack suit = business suit = lounge suit - default setting because frock coats and even tail coats are not all that common anymore!

Latest posts

Formality of Sack Suit vs Business Suit

Midnight Blue

Senior Member

AldenPyle

Distinguished Member

appolyon

Timed Out

Sator

Distinguished Member

Midnight Blue

Senior Member

Sator

Distinguished Member

sidvar

Senior Member

Classic Menswear Featured products

Latest posts

Similar threads

Featured Sponsor

How important is full vs half canvas to you for heavier sport jackets?

Definitely full canvas only

Half canvas is fine

Really don't care

Depends on fabric

Depends on price

Forum Sponsors

Members online

Forum statistics

FOLLOW STYLEFORUM ON:

Newest Posts

New Listings in Buying and Selling