What exactly are you trying to achieve?
I haven't had any experience with either of them, but judging by the brands, I'd go with the sculpting paste. I just feel like Gillette would have better products than Axe.
I've learned from personal experience, though, that it's not really about the product, more about how your hair dry. Try different techniques, like letting it dry messy, letting it dry flat/clean, towel drying, hair blower, ect. Right now my hair is about three inches long and I use only a tiny, tiny amount of product to hold my style. The advantage with this is that if it gets wet, then it won't turn greasy or go curly.