• We would like to welcome Arterton as an official Affiliate Vendor. Arterton, based in the UK, specializes in fine accessories such as garment bags, umbrellas, and shoe care, as well as fine shoes and boots from Yearn Footwear Please visit their thread and give them a warm welcome.

  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

What TV Series Are You Streaming Lately?

hpreston

Distinguished Member
Joined
May 10, 2011
Messages
2,046
Reaction score
3,245
The last slightly extended episode of The Expanse was, surprisingly, quite well-paced and while it was far from the best episode, it did the job.

I'd really like to see them come back from a new series that takes up the story in 30 years, as the books do from here... the showrunners have said it's not impossible, but that there will be a break now regardless.
It was good, but it makes the magic dog story inclusion all the more head scratching. I realize it was part of a novella, but it added nothing since the Laconia story wasn't going anywhere unless they renewed for more seasons.
I would have rather had more stuff with the core characters.
Agree with both of you.

I liked it, a lot even, but it felt just slightly rushed, maybe the last two episodes could have been just a bit longer.

Laconia story had really no payoff and seemed to be superfluous. Unless there is more (non book reader here…)

Every character got a nice payoff, Amos, Bobbie, peaches, etc.

The destruction of the Pella seemed just a bit too easy….

I thought Naomi’s emotions after destroying the Pella were gut wrenching, then I felt a bit cheated to find out Filip escaped.
 

Van Veen

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Jun 14, 2011
Messages
12,480
Reaction score
13,930
👀

The Pacific was good, Band of Brothers is like the gold standard. Its like Saving Private Ryan without as much gore but more stories. I mean, there's gore, just not as graphic as Ryan.
I haven't seen SPR in a long time, but it struck me that much of the gore/realism was front loaded, then we get an updated version of a 1940s/50s patriotic war film.

band of brothers was great in that it seemed not to stake out a position other than celebrating what citizen-soldiers went through in ww2. if you dig into the actual history a little more there are plenty of nits to pick, though. there are at least two prominent characters whose real-life stories were changed a little too much for me to be comfortable with.

the pacific was flawed, but realistically it could never be as good as band of brothers. there was not much to celebrate in the pacific theater. the combat episodes were as good as anything, and did a very good job of portraying things that we don't see very often because they do not translate to the screen very well. (the night battle at alligator creek) the material furthest removed from combat was the weakest, in part because some of it was completely made up. (at least bob ostensibly tried to stick to history. you can blame some of the inaccuracies on the source material [ambrose])

looking forward to masters of the air. it was stuck in development hell forever, but it's actually in production now. i've read the book, and i'm curious to see if they tackle some of the more difficult subjects.
 

patrick_b

Distinguished Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2007
Messages
4,753
Reaction score
5,870
band of brothers was great in that it seemed not to stake out a position other than celebrating what citizen-soldiers went through in ww2. if you dig into the actual history a little more there are plenty of nits to pick, though. there are at least two prominent characters whose real-life stories were changed a little too much for me to be comfortable with.
Which ones? I read Ambrose's book (though it was some 15 years ago so I don't remember many specifics) but watch the show every few years. If I came across an episode on History Channel or something, I'd start watching for a few minutes, then just start a rewatch on HBO Max. The characters and interpersonal relationships are so compelling and the casting is so perfect. So sad that a lot of the guys interviewed are no longer with us.

I've read that Sobel's family (David Schwimmer's character) was never happy with how he was portrayed. Makes sense.
 

FlyingMonkey

Distinguished Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2011
Messages
6,357
Reaction score
9,149
I would have rather had more stuff with the core characters.
To me, that's exacty why the series was getting tired. Apart from Drummer, who has just been going from strength to strength as a character, I was bored with almost everyting else, even Amos, which I never thought would happen. The Laconia sections opened things up a bit and reminded that this wasn't really about Earth or even the Solar System any more, and that humanity's future was going to be stranger than any of those involved in the fighting could imagine. For that matter I would have wanted more about what was going on for ordinary people on Earth, Mars and Belt - that was one of the strengths of the earlier seasons: that we got glimpses of all of those things.
 

Van Veen

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Jun 14, 2011
Messages
12,480
Reaction score
13,930
Which ones? I read Ambrose's book (though it was some 15 years ago so I don't remember many specifics) but watch the show every few years. If I came across an episode on History Channel or something, I'd start watching for a few minutes, then just start a rewatch on HBO Max. The characters and interpersonal relationships are so compelling and the casting is so perfect. So sad that a lot of the guys interviewed are no longer with us.

I've read that Sobel's family (David Schwimmer's character) was never happy with how he was portrayed. Makes sense.
The writers used Webster's character a little malleably. That's more on the show than Ambrose, though. Ambrose actually compiled and published his diaries.

Lt Dike also got a shit deal. He wasn't a coward as portrayed. Maybe this is because the men didn't actually like him, so their recollections were biased. He actually was wounded at Foy and didn't panic.

Blithe... The story in the show is correct. The epilogue isn't. He survived and stayed in the army, fought in Korea, and died of a perforated ulcer while on active duty in 1967.

Basically it seems like the show took some liberties with the dead characters and used them to make points.

There's also another, lesser-known historian who seems butthurt that he wasn't consulted for the show and nitpicks the shit out of it.

The misrepresentation of real people makes me uncomfortable. Imagine being Dike's grandchild and having everyone think of your grandfather as a coward, when in fact he was a war hero.

Don't get me wrong I love the show, which is what made me dig more into the history. I read the book a long time ago, though.
 

Featured Sponsor

Do You Own a Fountain Pen?

  • I own one but I hardly ever use it

  • I own multiple ones but I always use the same ol' BIC

  • Yes, and I use it often

  • Yes, I collect them

  • Ballpoint is the way


Results are only viewable after voting.

Related Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
469,236
Messages
10,043,125
Members
211,699
Latest member
Cnbisourews
Top