RJE
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 24, 2008
- Messages
- 556
- Reaction score
- 77
Following on from last year's thread.
I couldn't do the same thing - choosing a couple of dozen images out of the thousands on WAYWRN. My long list of decent images had 1048 shots. So, I chose what I felt were the best of many SFers' shots, resulting in fewer than one third of that. They're in alphabetical order. Here's a slideshow - once it opens, use the '-' bar to the left of 'seconds' at the bottom to reset it to 1 for a quick journey. Make it full screen with F11. It looks as if you have to click the play button if viewed from this link.
http://picasaweb.google.com/RJEbuyse...55305214568226
Here's the full album: useful if you're just scrolling down to find yourself!
http://picasaweb.google.com/RJEbuyse...WRNBestOf2010#
Some observations which come from looking at a lot of WAYWRN images over a short time.
I don't obsess over fit. There is no 'one fit' for each person, and I have moderate tolerance within difference styles for eg waist/shoulders/length. Something has to look obviously wrong to me almost immediately, without needing diagrams or rulers to try to explain it. I left in a PG shot that left me uncomfortable, as many others liked it.
So, colour/texture/pattern matching was important, hence the many detail shots.
JPHardy Your left shoulder often looks much more padded and higher than your right shoulder (I mean, well above the normal variation).
Some people (Gregaz!) are very rigid in the colours they feel go together, and you end up seeing a stream of almost identical variations. It was interesting to see that one suit Vaux posted twice in WAYWRN, had the same shirt and tie both times.
People whom I think routinely produce terrible combinations also routinely manage great ones (hello, Oldog!).
Doral is very matchy-matchy on ties/pocket squares. It's not altogether heinous.
(Each of these SFers is the list though
)
Sometimes people see beautiful fabric and say 'great suit/jacket'. They're different points.
I let a black shirt in.
Several SFers' images vanished. I think I did not include their (already saved) deleted images.
I don't like a wide lapel/big gorge matched with narrow spread button-downs.
Strangely, several Asian SFers had a common problem of a messy shirt collar, as if the tie twisted as they wrapped it around the neck, so that it bulges.
When not wearing ties, some people end up with one side of the shirt collar much higher than the other - resulting from a dressing habit? I know that even when not wearing a watch, one shirt sleeve can seem longer than the other because of the way I pull my jacket on.
Overcoat sleeves are long - if I can see your jacket or shirt sleeve, the overcoat sleeve is too short.
I was surprised how successful the weekly Challenges have been. They really do seem to encourage people to experiment or make a greater effort. They take effort to organise and have been a credit to Spoo. I would say though, requiring it to take place only on Fridays seems a bit narrow - I'd open it up for the whole week each time. But maybe this would dilute it?
There were some negatives to what I noticed, but...
The fireworks are firing...
I couldn't do the same thing - choosing a couple of dozen images out of the thousands on WAYWRN. My long list of decent images had 1048 shots. So, I chose what I felt were the best of many SFers' shots, resulting in fewer than one third of that. They're in alphabetical order. Here's a slideshow - once it opens, use the '-' bar to the left of 'seconds' at the bottom to reset it to 1 for a quick journey. Make it full screen with F11. It looks as if you have to click the play button if viewed from this link.
http://picasaweb.google.com/RJEbuyse...55305214568226
Here's the full album: useful if you're just scrolling down to find yourself!
http://picasaweb.google.com/RJEbuyse...WRNBestOf2010#
Some observations which come from looking at a lot of WAYWRN images over a short time.
I don't obsess over fit. There is no 'one fit' for each person, and I have moderate tolerance within difference styles for eg waist/shoulders/length. Something has to look obviously wrong to me almost immediately, without needing diagrams or rulers to try to explain it. I left in a PG shot that left me uncomfortable, as many others liked it.
So, colour/texture/pattern matching was important, hence the many detail shots.
JPHardy Your left shoulder often looks much more padded and higher than your right shoulder (I mean, well above the normal variation).
Some people (Gregaz!) are very rigid in the colours they feel go together, and you end up seeing a stream of almost identical variations. It was interesting to see that one suit Vaux posted twice in WAYWRN, had the same shirt and tie both times.
People whom I think routinely produce terrible combinations also routinely manage great ones (hello, Oldog!).
Doral is very matchy-matchy on ties/pocket squares. It's not altogether heinous.
(Each of these SFers is the list though
Sometimes people see beautiful fabric and say 'great suit/jacket'. They're different points.
I let a black shirt in.
Several SFers' images vanished. I think I did not include their (already saved) deleted images.
I don't like a wide lapel/big gorge matched with narrow spread button-downs.
Strangely, several Asian SFers had a common problem of a messy shirt collar, as if the tie twisted as they wrapped it around the neck, so that it bulges.
When not wearing ties, some people end up with one side of the shirt collar much higher than the other - resulting from a dressing habit? I know that even when not wearing a watch, one shirt sleeve can seem longer than the other because of the way I pull my jacket on.
Overcoat sleeves are long - if I can see your jacket or shirt sleeve, the overcoat sleeve is too short.
I was surprised how successful the weekly Challenges have been. They really do seem to encourage people to experiment or make a greater effort. They take effort to organise and have been a credit to Spoo. I would say though, requiring it to take place only on Fridays seems a bit narrow - I'd open it up for the whole week each time. But maybe this would dilute it?
There were some negatives to what I noticed, but...
The fireworks are firing...