Those two weren't the comparison, the two pictures you were seeing in that post were provided as proof that I am not just buying pairs of shoes that are on sale. Those two weren't my style so I passed on them even at a $175 discount per pair.
The comparison is a Goya 111 vs Picasso 110.
View attachment 1612917
View attachment 1612918
Congrats on not buying ugly shoes
To answer the question, I'm not a fan of either shoe because I don't really like a lot of broguing on an oxford.
That said I prefer the darker color and the more chiseled toe on the second pair.
For the STD's I prefer the SOH and have been eyeballing them for a while.
I also like the SOH loafers. I think both shoes would be better with the outfit you described. (Sport coat with polo)
That said like you I'm new at this, so take what I said with a big grain of salt.