venividivicibj
Stylish Dinosaur
- Joined
- Apr 9, 2013
- Messages
- 22,867
- Reaction score
- 18,388
Just looked up burgol, looks pretty nice, and looks cheaper (on a per mL basis) than saphir.
Last edited:
STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.
Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.
Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!
Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
DWF,
This is fascinating. Coming from a perfectionist cordwainer, who makes his own bespoke shoes, and has his own lasts, it makes one wonder whether lasted trees as important. Do lasted trees contribute anything useful that regular trees do not?
Just looked up burgol, looks pretty nice, and looks cheaper (on a per mL basis) than saphir.
If you like consistency shell isn't for you. Shell is incredibly inconsistent. I personally think you're being overly picky about a non-issue.After attempting to polish up my #8 boots, I'm unfortunately still running into problems and could use some advice. There seems to be almost a "line" where the finish appears different. On one side, it is more of a deeper reflection, where on the other, it's more shiny. I can't figure out why. My steps were: 1. Brush and wipe boot 2. Renovateur 3. Brush boot again 4. Apply Alden #8 paste wax sparingly, allow to dry 5. Brush 6. Polish with flannel cloth And this didn't seem to change anything about that "boundary" of the two finish lines. You can see it in my picture, between the two yellow arrows, which point to this divider. On the left, it's more of a dull shine. On the right, it's a very high shine. It's not that I don't like the way they look, but I would like it to be consistent. The weird part is that on the other boot, there is a consistent shine on the vamp, and it's a high shine, like the right side of this picture. Any suggestions? Should I not worry about it? Thanks.
The conditioner is good, but honestly if you're used to using renovateur and the like it is very different. It really conditions a lot and isn't like a disguised polish like Saphir's products are. Using it too heavy or frequently on dress shoes would smother them in oils and make them not take a shine well. His cream polishes are very similar except the proportions are different. Honestly these are probably all you really need for your shoes, the cream had enough coconut oil in there to condition plus the benefits of giving a shine. If you were to use one product it would be the cream polish, IMO. I have both and I pretty much never use the conditioner (used it on my briefcase a few times however) as I think it conditions "too much" for a formal dress shoe. I wouldn't be surprised if DW has a similar opinion.
Also, fwiw to further exacerbate the inconsistency with shell is that Alden slathers their own dye on their shell shoes to make it their "own". I have seen some really strange color variations in Alden shoes do to this process. Since shell is so fibrous and non porous it isn't going to absorb dyes uniformly. Alden's use of their own dyes it seems can only make this look more pronounced.If you like consistency shell isn't for you. Shell is incredibly inconsistent. I personally think you're being overly picky about a non-issue.
+1
Even if I thought that would be good (or necessary) for my shoes, I don't know where I would find the time.
^You do too much to your shoes.