• Hi, I am the owner and main administrator of Styleforum. If you find the forum useful and fun, please help support it by buying through the posted links on the forum. Our main, very popular sales thread, where the latest and best sales are listed, are posted HERE

    Purchases made through some of our links earns a commission for the forum and allows us to do the work of maintaining and improving it. Finally, thanks for being a part of this community. We realize that there are many choices today on the internet, and we have all of you to thank for making Styleforum the foremost destination for discussions of menswear.
  • This site contains affiliate links for which Styleforum may be compensated.
  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

    Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

The OCBD collar roll thread

srivats

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
3,907
Reaction score
53
I am starting this thread as a point of comparison/discussion for those of us in love with OCBDs. Much has been written about collar roll in different threads - I remember one of Vox's stellar posts - now only if I can remember where he posted that! Doc has also posted some excellent photos of his own ... I am going to find and add them here.

Just as a starter, here is a sample pic from one of my latest Mercer shirts:

pUMYRl.jpg
 

NewYorkIslander

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,003
Reaction score
5,627
Great idea Sri...I want some BD collars on my next few shirts, but am lost when it comes down to describing them...a photo would be perfect. I'm a big fan of PG's collar rolls.
 

MORNINGSTAR777

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Messages
466
Reaction score
111
I've owned: Club Monaco Polo Ralph Lauren Brooks Brothers Lands' End - Hyde Park, Original Oxford, Varsity Fit J. Crew Gap - Tailored Fit Out all my favorite overall is Brooks Brothers (the original of course), however I found that the now discontinued Lands' End Hyde Park OCBD has the best roll. Polo Ralph Lauren has the best feeling collar (feels like there's no interlining at all), but the collar points are too small to get a good roll; the same problem with CM, J. Crew and Gap. Below is an example of the Hyde Park
 

srivats

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
3,907
Reaction score
53
Originally Posted by MORNINGSTAR777
I've owned:

Club Monaco
Polo Ralph Lauren
Brooks Brothers
Lands' End - Hyde Park, Original Oxford, Varsity Fit
J. Crew
Gap - Tailored Fit

Out all my favorite overall is Brooks Brothers (the original of course), however I found that the now discontinued Lands' End Hyde Park OCBD has the best roll. Polo Ralph Lauren has the best feeling collar (feels like there's no interlining at all), but the collar points are too small to get a good roll; the same problem with CM, J. Crew and Gap.


I find the Mercer and BB collar rolls most pleasing to my eyes. BBBF, if it fits you, is excellent as well. Mercer shirts have no fusing/interling and that is part of the reason why they roll so well - the size on them is 3 7/16" which is slightly longer than BB. From what I understand, all their collars are hand attached as well.

Lands End comes next ... the hyde park is very good value for the money. I also have 2 older shirts from RL (no logo!) and they are terrific as well (no lining).
 

srivats

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
3,907
Reaction score
53
Some photos from the established members:

Originally Posted by DocHolliday
bwindow.jpg


(Chipp)

waywtweedtradchippbuttoned.jpg



Originally Posted by voxsartoria
Some BD pics, showing roll and tie space:

297826410_Ewrui-L.jpg


291832334_iyT2d-L.jpg


287499366_WKnWT-L.jpg


498679635_ndKbk-L.jpg


503969266_HJmme-L.jpg


628761477_a9HNR-L.jpg


307774933_U2f6S-L.jpg







Originally Posted by iammatt
Lots of roll:

tod011fj7.jpg


Less roll but very soft:

tod001rs7.jpg


I like them both ways, but the lack of tie space you have is killing the shirt. The Borrelli collars are really nicely shaped, but IMO are a bit too stiff.


Originally Posted by MAnton
Here's how I like mine to look:

CEGO:
p1020837gl9.jpg


Originally Posted by MAnton
Mercer:
p1020304lm7.jpg


p1020312ug1.jpg


Originally Posted by mafoofan
Over the years, I've bought more than a dozen OCBDs from Brooks Brothers and gave Mercer a crack. I would've tried J. Press, but their stock shirts are tents on me and they don't do made-to-measure OCBDs. Until now, no OCBD has completely satisfied me.

So, I decided to give Brooks Brothers' made-to-measure program another try--but this time, I implemented some modifications to the classic format.


OCBD1-1.jpg


To make the collar higher and improve the collar roll, I had them implement a two-button collar. The old, single-button collar tended to flatten on my neck; this one stays up and looks better with a jacket. In the interest of making the shirt dressier, I also replaced the standard placket with a French placket (or 'no placket', if you prefer).
 

DocHolliday

Stylish Dinosaur
Dubiously Honored
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
Messages
16,090
Reaction score
1,158
The BBBF strikes me as a caricature of the traditional roll. It's almost Eye-talian, and so I cast a suspicious eye upon it. But it's nice for wearing without a tie.

I have some vintage J. Press shirts that have a very nice roll despite the construction. A shame they feel compelled to keep tinkering with it. I like the flap pockets.

I did a week o' the white buttondown a while back, but I don't know if I still have the pics. Sero, old-school Brooks, Sulka, Press, etc. I'll dig around and see if I can find them.
 

forex

Distinguished Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
6,685
Reaction score
235
I found that BBBF collars are hit or miss,some of them make a really good roll to wear with ties but most of them look hideous so I wear them without a tie. I think same can be said about any button down shirt,it is hit or miss.
 

forex

Distinguished Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
6,685
Reaction score
235
Originally Posted by MORNINGSTAR777
I've owned:

Club Monaco
Polo Ralph Lauren
Brooks Brothers
Lands' End - Hyde Park, Original Oxford, Varsity Fit
J. Crew
Gap - Tailored Fit

Out all my favorite overall is Brooks Brothers (the original of course), however I found that the now discontinued Lands' End Hyde Park OCBD has the best roll. Polo Ralph Lauren has the best feeling collar (feels like there's no interlining at all), but the collar points are too small to get a good roll; the same problem with CM, J. Crew and Gap.

Below is an example of the Hyde Park


I really like this one,I wish all my OCBDs made such a roll,albeit only some of them turn out like that. Are these made in China ones?
 

NaturalShoulder

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2009
Messages
194
Reaction score
0
I wish my Hyde Park had a roll anywhere close to that. I like the tailored fit Hyde Parks and find the fabric good quality and love the price.

I have found Mercers have the best roll of shirts I have tried (Press, Hyde Park, Gitman, BB OTR, BB MTM), except for an older BB.
 

MORNINGSTAR777

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2007
Messages
466
Reaction score
111
Originally Posted by srivats
I find the Mercer and BB collar rolls most pleasing to my eyes. BBBF, if it fits you, is excellent as well. Mercer shirts have no fusing/interling and that is part of the reason why they roll so well - the size on them is 3 7/16" which is slightly longer than BB. From what I understand, all their collars are hand attached as well.

Lands End comes next ... the hyde park is very good value for the money. I also have 2 older shirts from RL (no logo!) and they are terrific as well (no lining).


I'd love to try BBBF, but being pretty tall and slim makes it impossible for me; I have to buy slim fit/extra slim fit BB in 15.5/36. I'd like to try a Mercer, but aren't they known for their full cut? I see you can order a shirt 2" slimmer, but I wonder if could request something smaller along the lines of BB slim fit?

Originally Posted by forex
I really like this one,I wish all my OCBDs made such a roll,albeit only some of them turn out like that. Are these made in China ones?

Yes, they are made in china.
 

voxsartoria

Goon member
Timed Out
Joined
Jan 18, 2007
Messages
25,700
Reaction score
180
Originally Posted by BBC
BB ocbd from the late 1960s

dfasdf001.jpg


Wow.

The outside breast pocket dates from '65 or '68...that and the "All Cotton" notation on the label, indeed, dates it to the late 60s. There would have to be care instructions on the label from '71 onward.

I won't ask where you got it or whom you killed.

Collar might be too small for you...


- B
 

BBC

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2009
Messages
875
Reaction score
4
Originally Posted by voxsartoria
Wow.

The outside breast pocket dates from '65 or '68...that and the "All Cotton" notation on the label, indeed, dates it to the late 60s. There would have to be care instructions on the label from '71 onward.

I won't ask where you got it or whom you killed.

Collar might be too small for you...


- B


Fortunately, it does fit albeit just a hair tight, but I like'm that way. I plan on wearing it infrequently and just in casual, open collar situations. The six-button front, instead of seven, also seems to help the overall look of the collar.

Picked it up from another forum member after searching for one for quite some time.
 

Featured Sponsor

Do You Consider Sustainability When Purchasing Clothes?

  • Always - Sustainability is a top priority in all my clothing purchases.

  • Often - I frequently consider sustainability, but it isn't the main factor in my decisions.

  • Rarely - I seldom consider sustainability when purchasing clothes.

  • Never - Sustainability is not a factor I consider in my clothing choices.


Results are only viewable after voting.

Forum statistics

Threads
510,088
Messages
10,616,494
Members
225,127
Latest member
Mark Angelil
Top