Suggested Black Captoe Shoes - POAL

[von Rothbart]

I picked Vass U Old English plain cap:

Seamless heel counter gives it a very clean look:

 

[bigbris1]

Originally Posted by aportnoy

I've got most of the shoes in the poll and besides my bespoke Cleverleys, my favorite is the Vass, but on the F not the U last. My second choice would be EG Chelsea on 202. The Lobbs are nice but lack the classic quality of the other two.

Originally Posted by teddieriley

I am certainly digging those pelhams. May now be top of the list, if I can find them on discount. Is that on the 888 or a different last? AP - thought about the Vass F last. Never tried it, however. Any idea how they fit compared to the U and comparative sizing?

Originally Posted by von Rothbart

I picked Vass U Old English plain cap
Heel/quarter seams/pieces or whatever discount the Vass & Pelhams. Get the Chelsea on the 202 and call it a day. Trust.

 

[teddieriley]

As an update, I decided on the Vass F last, Old English plain stich captoe in black with double Reddenbach sole taper to single with a closely trimmed sole. These are several hundred cheaper than the EG's at full retail. Will post pics when I get them.

 

[rioni]

Did you order them direct? how much were they?

 

[lasbar]

The John Lobb City II got only 3 votes.

It is a classic model versatile and elegant.

I don't get this EG fad...

 

[teddieriley]

Originally Posted by lasbar

The John Lobb City II got only 3 votes.

It is a classic model versatile and elegant.

I don't get this EG fad...

It's nice enough, but for not being prestige and costing over $1100 US, I rather go with Vass. Now if you know where I can kop for $500, I'd be interested.

 

[rioni]

I am going to go with a pair of black City II's after going through Valextra and then 888 EG's which didn't work for my feet. I really like the look of the City II's -- not exactly sure why they don't get more love on the forum.

Originally Posted by lasbar

The John Lobb City II got only 3 votes.

It is a classic model versatile and elegant.

I don't get this EG fad...

 

[culverwood]

Also C&J Whitehall a good blobby cap-toe

 

[chatty]

I know everyone loves the 888, but for a cap toe, I think the 202 works better

A plain cap-toe is a classic-conservative style, which is why I think the rounder toe matches better...imho

 

[upnorth]

black captoes = POAL, piece of absolute liability.

 

[teddieriley]

Originally Posted by teddieriley

As an update, I decided on the Vass F last, Old English plain stich captoe in black with double Reddenbach sole taper to single with a closely trimmed sole. These are several hundred cheaper than the EG's at full retail. Will post pics when I get them.

Just got these in. I may have a new favorite last in the F. Great, conservative looking shoe with style, and just what I wanted in a black captoe - understated elegance. Definitely worth the cash and the wait.

 

[sho'nuff]

Originally Posted by teddieriley

Looking for *the* black captoe shoe to own. I think after acquiring a pair, I'll be set for the next couple of years as far as dress shoes go. While price is a concern, I haven't set a strict budget. Probably should have been the first pair I picked up, but I worked backwards. I have very few formal events that I attend, nor does work require a pair. Not sure if I like the plain stitch or brogued cap, but leaning towards plain stitch.

I'm sure I can't go wrong with any of the poll choices, but interested to hear people's thoughts on what they have and reason for preference. Leaning towards Vass considering the value, but open to other suggestions.

Sutors can be found here http://cgi.ebay.com/New-850-Sutor-Ma...ht_2078wt_1167

Would appreciate if someone can identify the EG model (or models) I should consider.

teddie, i would recommend a pair of Ladbroke w/ HAF sole


edit*
or go with the F last pair that you decided on. both great choices.
good luck on getting the Vass accurately to your order though.

 

[sho'nuff]

Originally Posted by von Rothbart

I picked Vass U Old English plain cap:

sick

 

[ManofKent]

I went the EG Chelsea route, but I don't dislike any of your suggestions.

 

[TRINI]

Originally Posted by teddieriley

Just got these in. I may have a new favorite last in the F. Great, conservative looking shoe with style, and just what I wanted in a black captoe - understated elegance. Definitely worth the cash and the wait.

Pics?