• Hi, I am the owner and main administrator of Styleforum. If you find the forum useful and fun, please help support it by buying through the posted links on the forum. Our main, very popular sales thread, where the latest and best sales are listed, are posted HERE

    Purchases made through some of our links earns a commission for the forum and allows us to do the work of maintaining and improving it. Finally, thanks for being a part of this community. We realize that there are many choices today on the internet, and we have all of you to thank for making Styleforum the foremost destination for discussions of menswear.
  • This site contains affiliate links for which Styleforum may be compensated.
  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

    Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Sid Mashburn

yuoshie

New Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2016
Messages
3
Reaction score
1
I decided to do business with Sid Mashburn and I am underwhelmed.

When this started, I had one fully canvassed suit (from a different vendor) that needed tailoring and I had no backup to wear while the work was done. Soooo...

I bought one of Mashburn's suits to give me some depth to get my first suit altered. And, unfortunately, the tailoring (two separate sets of alts just to get it wearable!) didn't really impress me, but I needed to get my first suit altered so it would be more presentable and fit better. Then...I was going to continue letting them tweak their suit, until it was acceptable.

The problem is that when they returned my suit, it was scorched from having been pressed with an iron that was too hot. The lapels and the backs of the sleeves are particularly bad.

400


When I confronted them, they were not helpful and made no offer to resolve the situation. I explained that they scorched my jacket and the sales clerk responded that he'd never heard of that and their irons are set on the same temp all the time. Hmmm. He also said that they couldn't be certain when the problem occurred...and he just left that hanging in the air.

I left frustrated and a bit let down. On the way home I thought that'd I'd just make due - because I have a life and no time to fight with someone over things like this. Besides, I questioned myself. Had I made a mistake? Could I have caused this? Had I missed something?

However...

When I got home, I looked at the jacket in bright light and found it to be worse than my passing observations had originally noted. And, I knew I hadn't made a mistake or caused this. I'd even left a folded handkerchief in the front pocket and you could see where they'd ironed over it and left a square pressed into the garment. I no longer doubted myself...

For what it's worth, I own a steamer and I maintain my own clothing because cleaners have ruined my stuff previously.

400


If Sid Mashburn is what they claim to be, the person who worked on my suit knew they scorched it when it happened. Or...if they didn't...you have to conclude something else much less favorable. Soooo...once more into the breech!

I went back and pressed this point (no pun intended) with a sweeping gesture pointing back to their tailors I said, "I'm certain whoever did this, said 'oh ****!' out loud when it happened." The sales clerk actually said, "They didn't do it, we sent the jacket out."

What?!?!

If this doesn't bother you, at least consider that they previously said that 'their' irons were on the same temp all the time and now they're saying that they weren't even the ones doing the work...

For reference, I needed collar and center seem work and I wanted working buttons: $200+. When I originally got the jacket, they said they couldn't do the buttons and that it would only be $110.

So where am I now? I really liked my jacket. I know it isn't bespoke...and it may be plain blue...and it isn't ultra-trim styling (I'm not ultra-trim). But...it looked smashing on me! Now...not so much. Salt in the wound is that the tailoring of the Mashburn suit is completely uninspiring.

What's at stake here?

1. My suit looks like crap and it has to be replaced.
2. Their suit isn't what I'd want it to be and I'll have to pay someone else for alterations.
3. By refusing to acknowledge the situation, they're calling me a liar...as though I've made accusation that is baseless and not their problem.

The first two make me sad and make them incredibly 'common.' But the third leaves me outraged.

Finally, the manager did say, "well...all we can do now is say we're sorry." Then he turned away and walked off.

The sales clerk said, "just tell me what we can do to make this right." Now...I know I'm in the minority, but I refuse to negotiate. I also wonder why they hadn't said this the first time?!? I find the "just tell me what we can do" to be insulting. It is obvious what should be done, but asking me to negotiate it with you is a further insult. It's plebeian. It's an attempt to resolve a situation with an offer that is less than your best. It does not demonstrate respect...in fact, I find it excruciatingly offensive...like saying, "what is the least we could do to resolve the messed up situation we created in the first place?"

Also, FWIW, I labor to be, not a good customer, but a great customer. All of these things were purchased within weeks of getting the suit:

400
$300

400
$600
(3 Sid and 2 Drakes)

400
$100

Tailoring is everything. For most of us, it is the only thing. If you can't do bespoke (I can't) and you aren't the EXACT shape of the model that the suit was based upon, you must get your garment adjusted to fit you...or it will look like crap.

I do not have to wear a suit...I choose to wear a suit! The value of my choice is diminished by the problem they created.

I hope that this information is useful.
This is the suit I purchased at the Atlanta store:
http://www.sidmashburn.com/shop/tailored-clothing/navy-high-twist-kincaid-no-3-ticket-suit.html

Edit:
I was able to meet with Patrick this morning and I found him to be profession and empathetic. He labored to understand the nature of the problems and exerted real effort to maintain a genuine business relationship with me.

Patrick offered me coffee and took me to meet with one of their tailors. They reviewed my Mashburn suit and accounted for each of the adjustments necessary to improve the fit. When we were done with the pinning, the suit looked stellar! I am truly excited to see it when the changes are complete...

Then, we discussed my suit that they damaged. I got the distinct impression that I could have thrown a tantrum, acted in an undignified manner and...*pop*...out would have come a new suit to replace mine. But, I pride myself on being a gentleman first in all things (Hold your comments, because I care little for how you choose to keep yourself, if you differ from my position). A guy once said, "Why not rather be wronged? Why not rather be cheated?" That resonates in my mind every time I go in for the kill...and I'm defanged. Resolving situations in a mutually beneficial way leads to long term quality relationships...and restful sleep.

I asked that they refund the fee for the alterations and Patrick was uncomfortable by the idea that this hadn't been done already. Finally, the tension evaporated from the situation as he realized I wasn't there to eviscerate him. In an effort to acknowledge the situation and make concession for my position, he asked if I would receive one of their shirts as a sign of good faith...and I did:
700


http://www.sidmashburn.com/shop/spo...dot-broadcloth-spread-collar-sport-shirt.html
(-:

I recognize that these situations are awkward for everyone involved and I find no pleasure in the pain of others...I am neither an a$$hole nor a sadist. The truth is, stuff always goes wrong. Period. The measure of a man (or a business) is how he (they) handle it and overcome. Patrick rose to the occasion and demonstrated a professionalism in keeping with the image that Sid Mashburn is trying to display.

I am thankful for their effort and I look forward to putting this behind us. I will complete my update when we're done and I will post pictures of the results.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

pleatedjeans

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Messages
241
Reaction score
247
Maybe a few additional photos of your suit and the damage might make us better able to provide some advice/comments?
 

Sid Mashburn

New Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2016
Messages
1
Reaction score
5
Dear Sir,

I hope this finds you well.

We aim to exceed expectations, and no doubt this time we've fallen short. I'm so sorry your experience with us was not a great one. Although it was difficult to read, I truly appreciate you taking the time to offer us feedback.

I am very sorry to hear about the damage on your jacket. We are always very willing to look after outside alterations and to hear you have left unhappy is very disappointing. I would really like to see your jacket and see what we can do to resolve this. Additionally, it’s even more disappointing that you are not happy with the alterations on the suit you purchased from us. All your alterations were done in house and our expectations are that everyone walks out with the perfectly tailored suit and this is what we would like for you.

Your experience was not in line with our service offering, and we're very sorry. We guarantee our products. If you are not well pleased, we’ll make it right. We'd love the opportunity to make things right, starting by taking care of your Mashburn suit. If you'll give us a chance, we'd like to come to you to have it fitted, and deliver it back to you, finished within the week.

Please reach out to me directly at 404-350-7135, or at patrick.oshea@sidmashburn. I hope we have the opportunity to make amends for your first visit.

Kind Regards,

Patrick O’Shea
Store Director
 

comrade

Distinguished Member
Joined
May 10, 2005
Messages
8,988
Reaction score
2,286
My only impression of them is negative. A few years ago I ordered a pair
of canvas pants by phone and asked the rep for the rise measurement
which is not posted in a fitting chart the way Howard Yount- a much
smaller operation, has had on its' site for years. The rep measured
them but didn't include the waistband so the pants were returned.
I suggested that they post fitting charts. To this day no chart.
 
Last edited:

JohnnyMarr

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2012
Messages
86
Reaction score
13
Odd that someone would come in and their only post be an insult...wonder if he works for Sid Vicious, or whoever torched your jacket
 

vida

Senior Member
Joined
May 6, 2010
Messages
771
Reaction score
353
My only impression of them is negative. A few years ago I ordered a pair
of canvas pants by phone and asked the rep for the rise measurement
which is not posted in a fitting chart the way Howard Yount- a much
smaller operation, has had on its' site for years. The rep measured
them but didn't include the waistband so the pants were returned.
I suggested that they post fitting charts. To this day no chart.

I have purchased several suits, jackets and pants from Sid over the past 5 years. The last several items that I bought online had to be returned because of sizing inconsistency. I have always noticed some veriation but it now seems to have gotten worse. My feeling is that they have expanded too quickly and production has become an issue.
The store offers a good value but I don't plan on doing business there any time soon.
 

axedatta

Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2011
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
Sorry to bring this post back up, but I thought it would be relevant to my experience. Unfortunately, my experience with Sid was quite disappointing. I bought a suit last year that I loved (navy Kincaid cut). I was looking forward to becoming a regular customer and decided to pick up a pair of black whole cuts that just went on sale. After only one wearing, it turned out that the last was not for me, I had painful feet all day. So I immediately contact customer service and ask for an exchange for a different size OR I would also be happy to pay the difference for a full price shoe. After not hearing back for two days I decided to go in person to the Georgetown store in DC. I explain the situation, and I'm told the shoes, after one wearing, cannot be sold again and they cannot exchange them. I reiterate to customer service that I am willing to pay MORE to get a full price pair of shoes. The answer again is- sorry we cannot help you. This is from a store that sells $1000 Edward Green's and $3000 suits. (I should add that I never received a call from the store manager in DC to resolve the situation, only emails from the HQ)

The entire point of a place like Sid Mashburn is excellent customer service since folks these days can always find discounted luxury items online. A person goes to luxury physical stores to receive personal attention and accommodation. I have encountered better customer service from lesser luxury stores like Allen Edmonds and Nordstrom. Those places would never bat an eye in exchanging out a pair of shoes let alone turn away a customer who is willing to pay more to get a full price pair. The cost to Sid for resoling these shoes from his manufacturer would be a lot less than losing a potential lifelong customer. Maybe I'm not the ideal clientele for Sid, as most of the folks that come to the store are usually a Georgetown WASPY crowd. As a South Asian professional in the city, I certainly did not feel welcome or accommodated and my concerns were dismissed. Needless to say, I won't be shopping there again.
 

emptym

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Sep 22, 2007
Messages
9,659
Reaction score
7,364
^If Allen Edmonds and Nordstrom take back shoes after a customer wears them, then they would be very unusual exceptions. Most companies, including luxury ones, will not take back shoes after they've been worn, even once.

The best way to test a new pair of shoes is to wear them on carpet for a bit. Wearing them out all day will not only abrade the sole but set a crease line in the uppers and start an impression of your foot in the insole and/or cork.

It's possible that these shoes will break in and be comfortable. A new pair should be expected to be a little painful if worn all day on the first go. People here generally recommend wearing them a couple hours the first time, then working your way to a whole day.
 

saskatoonjay

Distinguished Member
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
1,647
Reaction score
2,200
Sorry to bring this post back up, but I thought it would be relevant to my experience. Unfortunately, my experience with Sid was quite disappointing. I bought a suit last year that I loved (navy Kincaid cut). I was looking forward to becoming a regular customer and decided to pick up a pair of black whole cuts that just went on sale. After only one wearing, it turned out that the last was not for me, I had painful feet all day. So I immediately contact customer service and ask for an exchange for a different size OR I would also be happy to pay the difference for a full price shoe. After not hearing back for two days I decided to go in person to the Georgetown store in DC. I explain the situation, and I'm told the shoes, after one wearing, cannot be sold again and they cannot exchange them. I reiterate to customer service that I am willing to pay MORE to get a full price pair of shoes. The answer again is- sorry we cannot help you. This is from a store that sells $1000 Edward Green's and $3000 suits. (I should add that I never received a call from the store manager in DC to resolve the situation, only emails from the HQ)

The entire point of a place like Sid Mashburn is excellent customer service since folks these days can always find discounted luxury items online. A person goes to luxury physical stores to receive personal attention and accommodation. I have encountered better customer service from lesser luxury stores like Allen Edmonds and Nordstrom. Those places would never bat an eye in exchanging out a pair of shoes let alone turn away a customer who is willing to pay more to get a full price pair. The cost to Sid for resoling these shoes from his manufacturer would be a lot less than losing a potential lifelong customer. Maybe I'm not the ideal clientele for Sid, as most of the folks that come to the store are usually a Georgetown WASPY crowd. As a South Asian professional in the city, I certainly did not feel welcome or accommodated and my concerns were dismissed. Needless to say, I won't be shopping there again.
Don’t be sorry, axedatta. I’ve never dealt with Sid Mashburn before and was doing some quick research this morning. Your post told me all I need to know: I should avoid this company. My research is done.

Thanks for letting people know!
 

axedatta

Member
Joined
Feb 2, 2011
Messages
19
Reaction score
6
^If Allen Edmonds and Nordstrom take back shoes after a customer wears them, then they would be very unusual exceptions. Most companies, including luxury ones, will not take back a show after it's been worn, even once.

The best way to test a new pair of shoes is to wear them on carpet for a bit. Wearing them out all day will not only abrade the sole but set a crease line in the uppers and start an impression of your foot in the insole and/or cork.

It's possible that these shoes will break in and be comfortable. A new pair should be expected to be a little painful if worn all day on the first go. People here generally recommend wearing them a couple hours the first time, then working your way to a whole day.

From first-hand experience, I can tell you those stores have done these exchanges. And I might even agree with you that those might be exceptions, but that is precisely the point. Those stores went out of there way to make sure a client was satisfied. In this situation, I was not even asking for my money back or an exchange. I was willing to pay the difference for a more expensive shoe. I was willing to give Sid more of my money to continue being a customer.
 

Featured Sponsor

How important is full vs half canvas to you for heavier sport jackets?

  • Definitely full canvas only

    Votes: 91 37.4%
  • Half canvas is fine

    Votes: 90 37.0%
  • Really don't care

    Votes: 26 10.7%
  • Depends on fabric

    Votes: 40 16.5%
  • Depends on price

    Votes: 38 15.6%

Forum statistics

Threads
506,853
Messages
10,592,484
Members
224,326
Latest member
uajmj15
Top