Which coat should I keep? You're trippin, the first one is much more visually interesting and, frankly, seems to elongate you. I like how it flares out at the bottom. Granted, small pics. And obviously shorten the sleeves. Just don't herk your arms up like that. Arms on #2 look gross, like sausage casings. I just don't think this overly fitted style is always great with fitted pants. Also, the higher gorge on #2 does you no favors in terms of height augmentation. I realize this runs contrary to perceived wisdom, but that's how it looks. Advice for short people: not everything you wear has to be perfectly fitted and proportionally the same size. Embrace the drape.