Which jacket or none? No real need but felt the need for a casual jacket so i wouldnt have to fuss around so much with wearing blazers and if the right amount of cuff was showing. THey're all about the same price, within $100. If they both fit you as well as they fit those models (admittedly unlikely), then for $100 a pop I'd probably get both. That is if this is the price range you are looking at for your clothes. If you're looking to up your price bracket in the future then I'd get the trench as you can better realise the price difference in peacoats compared to trenches.