• Hi, I am the owner and main administrator of Styleforum. If you find the forum useful and fun, please help support it by buying through the posted links on the forum. Our main, very popular sales thread, where the latest and best sales are listed, are posted HERE

    Purchases made through some of our links earns a commission for the forum and allows us to do the work of maintaining and improving it. Finally, thanks for being a part of this community. We realize that there are many choices today on the internet, and we have all of you to thank for making Styleforum the foremost destination for discussions of menswear.
  • This site contains affiliate links for which Styleforum may be compensated.
  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

    Styleforum is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Shoe Damage & Appreciation Central HOF (no ugly vintage shoos need apply)

NORE

Distinguished Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
348
Since the SD&PC thread went to crap I decided to do a HOF thread highlighting some of the shoos that actually constitute Appreciation. This thread is not for pics of the McMethod, vintage crap etc. so please respect. Starting with Pt2 and hopefully will be able to extract some pieces from the original thread. Ppp 1&2:
Originally Posted by guster
Those are nice Oyaji.

Thanks, they are my favorite one.

Here another pair of mine, G&G St James (from Bespoke-England), always showing left foot pics as it is my "worst" foot:
b4faf424-8ce0-47ce-9533-80a38c4344da.JPG

33496888-c855-4229-9270-5e1cfc793f5c.JPG

2ed062f7-702e-4f9f-9abf-6e83b0358f87.JPG

2e64db1b-2db0-4fa0-b223-f8946dcf0837.JPG
Another purchase this week...

_DSC3920.jpg
Originally Posted by bigbris1
Nice! I'm hesitant to place an order because I can't get a good sense of their colors from web pics. Is this vintage rioja, rosewood or cherry on the TG73?

Originally Posted by Slewfoot
It seems like more of a Chestnut color to me. Also, I'm guessing that's the MH71 last as it seems to be more of a soft square toe. I personally prefer the MH71 much more than the TG73 which appears too elongated. I have yet to pull the trigger on a pair of G&G's. Not sure I ever will to be honest.

MH71 in Vintage Cherry. I also prefer them to TG73, here are my TG73 (Gable in Vintage Oak):
4b4a2301-868f-4e25-be3a-e90d98b884a1.JPG

e5fb0ff3-6217-48f8-8140-ac56430c03ac.JPG

31e078c8-b83f-47ab-87e4-88672a25d9bd.JPG

ebdd5b5d-f0b4-42b7-ba2a-c5c20a1bed12.JPG
Originally Posted by SpooPoker
Your black Barker Blacks dont deserve shoe trees?
frown.gif


Very nice collection. The Barker Black Archdale in Antique Chestnut is one sweet looking pairs of shoes.
boxing[1].gif


dsc0582gj9.jpg
The Archdale Spectator in Brown/Suede is also very very nice......
inlove.gif
BBSpectators07.jpg
Originally Posted by Amar ezzahi
Are you crazy? It might fall!
Thank you for asking. I think I am on Style forum average.
Originally Posted by Sterling Gillette
"Those G&G shoes which fell onto my head were so beautifull that I died the very moment they hit me."
Originally Posted by bengal-stripe
It’s fun to die, if you are hit by the right footwear:
Couldnt happen (sorry for Goethe): I took small risk on that shot (Japan is rather famous for earthquake), I put some tape on the sole during the picture.

Originally Posted by zjpj83
Awesome shine!
Actually G&G leather is really easy to polish.

Here my brown EG Cadogan (my favorite)
fc104417-151e-46aa-a75d-b63650b77d48.jpg

d4c744fd-c297-4ece-8d4c-eb8bb24137b0.jpg

deb90e23-d9f8-4d3e-a8f9-eadfd93d4352.jpg

b2f703e1-c5cb-4bed-be20-21c02cac672f.JPG

f8491247-aa75-4794-a5b7-94cc638c8960.JPG
Cross posted from Balmoral Boots:

My 2c (and counting).




All feedback welcome.
Still finding gaps in my shoe wardrobe. This weeks arrival...

_DSC3898.jpg
Today, my favorite shoes: G&G Harrow (GG06-Expresso Calf):
Naked:
084e978d-3a03-4ce0-9292-bc0964920f03.jpg

b06bec41-2045-4b90-8542-5eb7a090d428.jpg

e17356aa-79d1-4993-a623-7f3ac9a0a591.jpg

3cca8ee1-1687-40fe-80ff-77b0685cb735.jpg


With lace:
398c2e24-3469-4cf6-a3f0-09fd1cbff479.JPG

df7a34b1-288b-4922-ba0f-5dee80ec2a2a.JPG

eedbf638-5ca6-40f4-a87d-3151627b5106.JPG
Work in progress...

standard.jpg


standard.jpg
Don't believe I've shared these:





 

NORE

Distinguished Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
348
pp 3&4: [
CJ Drummond

J.Lobb Spectator (Off course those are my favorite)
14703e8e-2201-4fee-945f-13502629d936.jpg

9af7ba28-5d7b-4203-ae6d-eb3810fc8b32.jpg
Here my EG Chelsea in 202, a classic (& my favorite)
cf780e26-dc59-46e1-be86-a0fd74b29910.jpg

b65c06b5-dc80-417d-81da-e1bc1d228e9b.JPG

10811542-789c-445b-bed8-0f9d5d129f78.JPG

ec1e692c-bacd-4762-9e47-f44ccf3c2b95.jpg
just been having a play around with my album

R0011480-1.jpg


R0011345-1.jpg
Hi Guys

Here is my most recent damage:
picture051m.jpg
[/IMG]
Noticed the disussion on Corthay and just wanted to chime in. I purchased these Arca's in July of 08 and have had zero issues with them construction wise. They were a touch snug on purchase (but not uncomfortable) and after a wear or two the fit was perfect. What I have found remarkable is the almost total lack of creasing. No other shoes I have owned (C&J, Grenson, Heschung - sorry no Lobb's, EG's or Vass to compare to) have come close in this category. My Corthay's are the only shoes I own that have lasted trees so I assume that has a lot to do with it - but I remain impressed and assume that quality construction and leather must play a role as well. (FWIW I clean and condition once a month with mostly Allen Edmonds conditioners and creams - same as all my other shoes.) This is the first time I have ever attempted to post pictures (to any site) so hopefully they appear and are decent.
IMG_0350.jpg
IMG_0352.jpg
IMG_0411.jpg
IMG_0457.jpg
IMG_0339.jpg
My new aquisition:

p1010010u.jpg


p1010018h.jpg


p1010015pl.jpg


p1010012p.jpg


First shoe by a French maker.

Personally I am kind of impressed by the shoes, at least for the price I was paying. I wouldn't have expected the channeled soles, as the pics on the website indicate that they usually have not...

Not sure about the leather quality though. My untrained eye can't spot any differences to my other shoes, but we will see.
 
Last edited:

NORE

Distinguished Member
Joined
Dec 3, 2010
Messages
5,430
Reaction score
348
pp 5&6:
These might send some to sleep or repel others, but I finally got a decent Dainite sole black shoe:
eg_cardiff_2.jpg
eg_cardiff_1.jpg
eg_cardiff_3.jpg
eg_cardiff_5.jpg
eg_cardiff_4.jpg
eg_cardiff_6.jpg
Ebayed NIB for a very reasonable price. My commute involves walking 4 miles a day on a mixture of tarmac, unmade roads and gravel paths - not so bad when it's dry, but in wet weather it can eat leather, and these will do when I want to spare the EG chelseas with a suit, but are casual enough for a sportscoat.
Originally Posted by Sebastian
My new aquisition:
p1010010u.jpg
p1010018h.jpg
p1010015pl.jpg
p1010012p.jpg
First shoe by a French maker. Personally I am kind of impressed by the shoes, at least for the price I was paying. I wouldn't have expected the channeled soles, as the pics on the website indicate that they usually have not... Not sure about the leather quality though. My untrained eye can't spot any differences to my other shoes, but we will see.

I'm surprised by the lack of comments on these. These are very cool shoes!
I just picked up these Brooks English, which, after consultation in the maker's thread, appear to be made by Cheaney. I've been wanting a good pair of black punch caps, and these are exactly the sort of thing I wanted. I'm not sure how old they are. I've included a picture of the shoe box label, which has detached from the box. That isn't the original price (it's the top of a stack of price tags).
img0183es.jpg
img0186j.jpg
img0187gf.jpg
img0190jk.jpg
img0193iu.jpg
New Acquisition: a whole cut in summer color
img6919e.jpg
img6920r.jpg
img6921k.jpg
Church's Sidford Wingtips, X-post from B&S
P1030821.jpg
P1030825.jpg
P1030824.jpg
My first English made shoes.. Joseph Cheaney for Lane Crawford. I was supposed to buy c&j westbourne but I need a pair of dark brown captoes. Hope I made the right decision. What can you say about the quality of these shoes?
DSC_0145.jpg
DSC_0151.jpg
DSC_0147.jpg
DSC_0146.jpg
DSC_0148.jpg
DSC_0149.jpg
DSC_0150.jpg
St. Crispin's
016.JPG
011.JPG
012.JPG
I am not really a fan of black shoes but these are ridiculously good looking. I wish EG was within my pay grade. Picture is from blog.leffot.com
DSC_0008.jpg
DSC_0017.jpg
I got these very cheap from E-bay, 92 pounds including new cedar shoe trees and shipping to Sweden. They are Alfred Sargent Dulwich, from the classic collection (rubber heel and not fully leather lined). I can't feel the difference in suede quality between these and the AS Thin Red Line suede brogues though, it looks to be exactly the same:
Dulwich1.jpg
Dulwich2.jpg
Dulwich3.jpg
Possibly more suitable for Streetwear: Received these NDC wingtips today (ordered from Yoox). Comparable to Paul Smith Miller
830422650_qaMxL-S-1.jpg
830423287_JLEie-S-1.jpg
830423106_ZMGuF-S.jpg
Stefano Branchini boots bought from Venice, Italy during the Easter weekend.
830423524_MXEjQ-S-1.jpg
830423983_cUv6R-L.jpg
830423701_3SG6K-L.jpg
I was familiar with the StefanoBi brand, I was not sure that is the same guy starting both brands. Obviously these are the lower-end Branchini. I paid 210 euros on sale (350 euro full price). There were a few other models on sale, but either not my size or too fancy (e.g blue and grey suede). I have not seen any good-year or norwegese Branchini and the styles were hit or miss, I was surprised to find that here on SF that hey are highly regarded.
Picked up two pairs of new dark brown shoes in the last month. Borrelli by Sutor in dark brown and my must have shoe that I've been eyeing since I joined SF - the EG Asquith in Dark Oak.
Asquith1.jpg
Asquith2.jpg
Asquith3.jpg
Borrelli1.jpg
Borrelli2.jpg
Borrelli3.jpg
Borrelli4.jpg
My new Bally Scribe Aken in tan (have them in black too but haven't gotten around to taking pics of them yet). Both the leather the construction are fantastic. I could not be happier with them.
BallyScribeAken001_edited.jpg
BallyScribeAken002_edited.jpg
BallyScribeAken003.jpg
BallyScribeAken004.jpg
And my new Bally Scribe Alban in tan:
BallyScribeAlban003_edited.jpg
BallyScribeAlban001_edited.jpg
BallyScribeAlban002_edited.jpg
BallyScribeAlban004_edited.jpg
Full disclosure: I have some of the same shoes for sale in the B&S forum.
Bottom line: Silvestro Shoes are highly recommended. Guys, Many months ago, Paolo from Silvestro introduced his company to this thread. Impressed by the way he handled questions and by the website (see link below), I ordered a pair"”Goldoni in the 30711 last in Antique 113. My verdict: elegant last, beautiful leather and finish, meticulous workmanship. Excellent service, too. I'm eagerly awaiting two more pair, Machiavelli 2 and Pavese. On sizing: I recommend consulting the third "male" row (Italian flag) of the chart linked below. I'm a fairly consistent 10½ US, and since most charts convert that size to a 43.5 or 44 Euro, I originally ordered a 44"”which were too big. No problems exchanging, and my new pair of 43 fit perfectly. Paolo's email and phone are on the website. Feel free to pm me if I'm not responding to thread questions. (Notes: pictures were taken after wearing them a day and in varied lighting; and I have no relationship with Silvestro...just an average SF dude.) Best, ETB http://www.calzoleriasilvestro.com/c...=26&idLingua=2 http://www.runtheplanet.com/resource...conversion.asp
 

rikod

Distinguished Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2010
Messages
1,365
Reaction score
567
Ok, will these qualify?, not mine but they are maybe the only pair in the U last that I desire

 

Stirling

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Messages
524
Reaction score
58
Your shoes are lovely Namor. I take it you wear them to work.
 

Burton

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
1,695
Reaction score
229
Thanks for creating this thread. This makes me just want to buy a pair to post up here--let's make sure it does not become polluted with crud.
 

Featured Sponsor

How important is full vs half canvas to you for heavier sport jackets?

  • Definitely full canvas only

    Votes: 85 37.3%
  • Half canvas is fine

    Votes: 87 38.2%
  • Really don't care

    Votes: 24 10.5%
  • Depends on fabric

    Votes: 36 15.8%
  • Depends on price

    Votes: 36 15.8%

Forum statistics

Threads
506,483
Messages
10,589,823
Members
224,252
Latest member
ColoradoLawyer
Top