Shawl collar - William lockie vs RLPL or another?

[noobanker]

I’m looking for a heavy shawl collar sweater for casual attire.
I’ve had a cotton light one from Brooks Brothers in large which fit me well, and a Zegna 100% cashmere which is a bit loose but passable.

I recently bought a William Lockie wool shawl in large and it was way too baggy - long arms, long body, and chest to roomy.
I don’t know if going for a medium will solve the issue because I am not sure I like the cut overall.

another option would be RLPL cashmere one, which appears to be less heavy but having owned many RLPL knitwear, I really enjoy the overall aesthetic and design language of the brand. But it would not be the heavy winter shawl I was originally looking for.

anyone have any experience with either William Lockie or RLPL shawl collar sweater? Or perhaps the Permanent style one? Any recommendations or advice would be greatly appreciated

 

[Camerashy]

Good News - Also consider this one from PWVC

The Cashmere Shawl Cardigan

Our 100% cashmere shawl cardigan neck is super soft and extremely luxurious, crafted from only the finest Scottish cashmere. Relaxed fit 100% cashmere Inset sleeve Five gauge rib Shawl collar cardigan with two pockets Roll back cuffs Loop and button neck fastening Real horn British-made buttons...

www.privatewhitevc.com

Bad News - just missed out on 40% off BF deal

OR Colhays

 

[Howfener]

I bought mine from Campbells of Beauly and recommend them highly for knitwear generally.

Shawl Collar Cardigan - Campbell's of Beauly

Men's 4 ply lambswool cardigan stitch shawl collar cardi. Made in Scotland. An essential winter warmer for the contemporary man's wardrobe.

www.campbellsofbeauly.com

 

[Mirage-]

I bought mine from Campbells of Beauly and recommend them highly for knitwear generally.

Shawl Collar Cardigan - Campbell's of Beauly

Men's 4 ply lambswool cardigan stitch shawl collar cardi. Made in Scotland. An essential winter warmer for the contemporary man's wardrobe.

www.campbellsofbeauly.com

It is interesting to learn I've been demoted from IT48/M to XS according to their sizes 😂

 

[Howfener]

It is interesting to learn I've been demoted from IT48/M to XS according to their sizes 😂

Certainly their sizing flatters the larger gentlemen!

 

[noobanker]

I bought mine from Campbells of Beauly and recommend them highly for knitwear generally.

Shawl Collar Cardigan - Campbell's of Beauly

Men's 4 ply lambswool cardigan stitch shawl collar cardi. Made in Scotland. An essential winter warmer for the contemporary man's wardrobe.

www.campbellsofbeauly.com

how heavy is the 4-ply?
I like the light grey which is not available from many of the aforementioned vendors

 

[DorianGreen]

I’m looking for a heavy shawl collar sweater for casual attire.
I’ve had a cotton light one from Brooks Brothers in large which fit me well, and a Zegna 100% cashmere which is a bit loose but passable.

I recently bought a William Lockie wool shawl in large and it was way too baggy - long arms, long body, and chest to roomy.
I don’t know if going for a medium will solve the issue because I am not sure I like the cut overall.

another option would be RLPL cashmere one, which appears to be less heavy but having owned many RLPL knitwear, I really enjoy the overall aesthetic and design language of the brand. But it would not be the heavy winter shawl I was originally looking for.

anyone have any experience with either William Lockie or RLPL shawl collar sweater? Or perhaps the Permanent style one? Any recommendations or advice would be greatly appreciated

Is your Zegna this one?

It looks absolutely gorgeous.

 

[Howfener]

how heavy is the 4-ply?
I like the light grey which is not available from many of the aforementioned vendors

Feels nice and heavy to me, though I’m no connoisseur and haven’t got anything to compare it to.

 

[noobanker]

Does it look as heavy or less heavy than this?

Feels nice and heavy to me, though I’m no connoisseur and haven’t got anything to compare it to.

 

[Howfener]

View attachment 1864217
Does it look as heavy or less heavy than this?

Maybe very slightly less heavy

 

[DorianGreen]

View attachment 1864217
Does it look as heavy or less heavy than this?

This is a 12ply, you won't find anything heavier.

 

[Gus]

If you get to NYC visit De Corato. They will do a MTO or MTM cashmere sweater by Fedeli so it is adjusted to your measurements. It is a wonderful 9 ply. He has one on hand to try on. I think this cream color is especially handsome.

 

[DorianGreen]

If you get to NYC visit De Corato. They will do a MTO or MTM cashmere sweater by Fedeli so it is adjusted to your measurements. It is a wonderful 9 ply. He has one on hand to try on. I think this cream color is especially handsome.

View attachment 1864235

Really nice.

 

[noobanker]

If you get to NYC visit De Corato. They will do a MTO or MTM cashmere sweater by Fedeli so it is adjusted to your measurements. It is a wonderful 9 ply. He has one on hand to try on. I think this cream color is especially handsome.

View attachment 1864235

How much is it?

 

[noobanker]

This is a 12ply, you won't find anything heavier.

Yeah I guess that is the heaviest you'll find.