Willpower recommended the Antico Caruso a while back. The Mark Birley gets good reviews. What didn't you like about it? Antico Caruso is nice if you're a fan of almond/vanilla. Some compare it to Le Male, but it's far better. Still, if you're not into almonds, pass. Mark Birley is OK, it's just underwhelming. Very polite, safe, a bit more obnoxious than Gendarme, an office scent.