Athomas
Member
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2010
- Messages
- 6
- Reaction score
- 0
Hi,
Does anyone have any thoughts on how Saphir Renovateur is Mink-oil based? A simple search will yield many posts touting the quality of Renovateur, but at the same time, you have, probably just as many people bad-mouthing mink oil. So what's the deal? Is Renovateur good for high-end shoes/leather or not? If it's "good", then does that invalidate all of the negative reviews about mink oil?
Also, is the general consensus on museum calf not to use conditioner? I've used both Lexol and Renovateur and both not only darken leather, but strip the finish as well. I don't want dry and cracked shoes but surely would like to preserve the original color of my shoes. Read a post a day or so back where one member completely stripped the beautiful finish on a pair of Lobbs using what a JL representative told him to use: A cream in the same color shade as the shoe. So what to do? Refrain from using creams and conditioners?
Not extremely knowledge about leather or the process in which they use to dye the leather, but I've read that some finishes are due to tanning and can't be removed via creams or conditioners (not sure how accurate that is, though) and other finishes are achieved by using different polishes and waxes and what have you, and thus why cream and conditioner are able to remove said finish. So considering most people won't know which is which (unless they do some kind of spot test, which I personally wouldn't want to do), is the only option not to use creams or conditioners on anything besides shoes that are of a solid color?
Thanks,
-A
Does anyone have any thoughts on how Saphir Renovateur is Mink-oil based? A simple search will yield many posts touting the quality of Renovateur, but at the same time, you have, probably just as many people bad-mouthing mink oil. So what's the deal? Is Renovateur good for high-end shoes/leather or not? If it's "good", then does that invalidate all of the negative reviews about mink oil?
Also, is the general consensus on museum calf not to use conditioner? I've used both Lexol and Renovateur and both not only darken leather, but strip the finish as well. I don't want dry and cracked shoes but surely would like to preserve the original color of my shoes. Read a post a day or so back where one member completely stripped the beautiful finish on a pair of Lobbs using what a JL representative told him to use: A cream in the same color shade as the shoe. So what to do? Refrain from using creams and conditioners?
Not extremely knowledge about leather or the process in which they use to dye the leather, but I've read that some finishes are due to tanning and can't be removed via creams or conditioners (not sure how accurate that is, though) and other finishes are achieved by using different polishes and waxes and what have you, and thus why cream and conditioner are able to remove said finish. So considering most people won't know which is which (unless they do some kind of spot test, which I personally wouldn't want to do), is the only option not to use creams or conditioners on anything besides shoes that are of a solid color?
Thanks,
-A