I'm curious as to what insoles everyone wears in their boots. Probably varies greatly. I need a replacement pair of the red RM insoles but could just as easily get another type locally. Thanks in advance. I use Green SuperFeet insoles. My US size is a 11 or 11.5 D. I have relatively wide feet but not wide enough to need wides in US sized shoes. I made the mistake of trying on comfort craftsman at the Manhattan store (and settled on the 10.5 G/Wide) though when I decided to order my RMW's from Barry/bootsonline, I decided against the comfort model in favor of the standard craftsman (wanted leather sole). Because of this, there was more room than I wanted so I bought the green SuperFeet insoles and all is well. They were actually a bit more snug than I hoped but within a few days of wear, they stretched a bit making them ultra comfortable. When I bought my second pair of Craftsman, I went with the same formula, allowing me to again use the superfeet insoles. That's how much I like the superfeet insoles.