Ralph Lauren Camelhair Polo Coat

[TheShetlandSweater]

Here’s a recent article. Nice read.

The Aristocrat of Topcoats: Boyer on the Polo Coat - Ivy Style

Over the past dozen years, Ivy Style has been honored to digitize for the Internet the work of legendary menswear historian G. Bruce Boyer, thereby making it available to a new generation of readers. In this post Mr. Boyer ruminates on the polo coat, the so-called “aristocrat of topcoats.” Below...

www.ivy-style.com

A recent article from 1981.

 

[Phileas Fogg]

A recent article from 1981.

Yes! I am Connor MacLeod, of the clan MacLeod.

Actually I skipped over the italicized portion right to the body. I see what you mean now. Still a good read.

 

[LouisDavout]

Here is another option https://alexanderkraft.com/pure-camel-hair-ak-mc-polo-overcoat.html

 

[adrianvo]

Beautiful, but I'm not loving the chest flap-pocket.

 

[Phileas Fogg]

Here is another option https://alexanderkraft.com/pure-camel-hair-ak-mc-polo-overcoat.html

I’m always a bit put off when the claim of “one of Italy’s most renowned mills” or something to that extent is used in the description or ad copy.

It makes me think there’s a reason that the one does not want to be directly associated with the other.

At a price point of ~$1500, I don’t like such vagueness.

 

[dukeaw]

I just got the Anthology polo coat. I'm very impressed. Heavy yet soft fabric. It has impeccable finishing. I would argue it is higher quality than the RL one. I believe it has more tailored shape than the RL coat. Its is incredibly high quality and even a slightly more affordable price

The Anthology x Permanent Style Polo Coat — The Anthology

100% Camelhair A luxury Polo Coat designed in close collaboration with Simon Crompton of Permanent Style, arguably the leading authority of classic & luxury menswear. Full article about the collaboration here . Designed and crafted with utmost attention to detail, this overcoat is

theanthology.net

 

[stifler]

I just got the Anthology polo coat. I'm very impressed. Heavy yet soft fabric. It has impeccable finishing. I would argue it is higher quality than the RL one. I believe it has more tailored shape than the RL coat. Its is incredibly high quality and even a slightly more affordable price

The Anthology x Permanent Style Polo Coat — The Anthology

100% Camelhair A luxury Polo Coat designed in close collaboration with Simon Crompton of Permanent Style, arguably the leading authority of classic & luxury menswear. Full article about the collaboration here . Designed and crafted with utmost attention to detail, this overcoat is

theanthology.net

What makes it better than the RL polo coat?

The Anthology is sold out in size 40 and every other size basically. Is their online inventory not accurate?

 

[dukeaw]

What makes it better than the RL polo coat?

The Anthology is sold out in size 40 and every other size basically. Is their online inventory not accurate?

I didnt realize it was sold out. You could email them and ask if they have more being made.

It is a partly hand made garment. The quality of the stitching is impeccable. They did not leave any detail overlooked. More of the price is towards quality of construction.

I cannot speak to the RL coat, but I would imagine it is a machine made garment. With the RL garment you are paying for the RL name and good quality garment. More of the price is towards the RL label

The Anthology coat is much more structured and shaped. the RL one is more loose and boxy.

 

[Viral]

I didnt realize it was sold out. You could email them and ask if they have more being made.

It is a partly hand made garment. The quality of the stitching is impeccable. They did not leave any detail overlooked. More of the price is towards quality of construction.

I cannot speak to the RL coat, but I would imagine it is a machine made garment. With the RL garment you are paying for the RL name and good quality garment. More of the price is towards the RL label

The Anthology coat is much more structured and shaped. the RL one is more loose and boxy.

so you own both? That's awesome!

Can you post some side-by-side pics?

 

[dukeaw]

so you own both? That's awesome!

Can you post some side-by-side pics?

I dont own both, just the Anthology one. Just speaking from what I've seen of RL garments.

here is the post about the Anthology polo coat with pics

Permanent Style

Designing the Anthology polo coat

www.permanentstyle.com

 

[stifler]

I didnt realize it was sold out. You could email them and ask if they have more being made.

It is a partly hand made garment. The quality of the stitching is impeccable. They did not leave any detail overlooked. More of the price is towards quality of construction.

I cannot speak to the RL coat, but I would imagine it is a machine made garment. With the RL garment you are paying for the RL name and good quality garment. More of the price is towards the RL label

The Anthology coat is much more structured and shaped. the RL one is more loose and boxy.

Thanks. I'm looking for a polo coat with no shoulder padding or roping. Would that be the RL polo coat then?

 

[dukeaw]

Thanks. I'm looking for a polo coat with no shoulder padding or roping. Would that be the RL polo coat then?

Unfortunately I cant speak to the RL one's specific makeup other than what I can see in the pics. Knowing RL's typical style it would probably be a more trad american aesthetic which is softer shoulders. But I'm just some rando on the internet that hasnt seen the RL one in person

 

[Viral]

I dont own both, just the Anthology one. Just speaking from what I've seen of RL garments.

here is the post about the Anthology polo coat with pics

Permanent Style

Designing the Anthology polo coat

www.permanentstyle.com

oh.......interesting. Then how can you say one is better than the other?

 

[dukeaw]

oh.......interesting. Then how can you say one is better than the other?

Its just the opinion of some rando on the internet based on some assumptions... Also, whats better for me isnt whats better for you. stifler wanted softer shoulders. the Anthology coat is very structured, so it may not be what is better for him. There is no best. They are both good. I just felt that I was getting better value and higher quality with the Anthology one. I dont care about brands. Buying the RL one is buying the known quality and reputation of RL which Anthology doesnt have

 

[stifler]

I wonder how the J. Press polo coat is:

CAMEL DOUBLE BREASTED POLO COAT

Browse the Camel Double Breasted Polo Coat, or shop though our selection of suits, dress shirts, or sportswear. View the Camel Double Breasted Polo Coat.

jpressonline.com