Please critique the fit of my shirt

[sartoriale1]

I would like to know what people think about the fit of my first made-to-measure shirt. I am thinking of having slimmer sleeves.

Please give me your opinions.

pic1 pic2

 

[anon]

does the collar close? it looks like it would be extremely tight. and how does it fit on your chest/stomach? it looks a little big from the front. I suppose the sleeves could also use a little slimming

 

[foto010101]

edit

 

[Limniscate]

Sleeves seem a little long like on my latest MTMs. Will it shrink with washings?

 

[foto010101]

edit

 

[flipster]

I wouldn't slim down the sleeves.. They're alright IMO

 

[onix]

The sleeves are ok, but there is something not right with the chest area. How about button your collar up?

 

[sartoriale1]

Originally Posted by anon

does the collar close? it looks like it would be extremely tight. and how does it fit on your chest/stomach? it looks a little big from the front. I suppose the sleeves could also use a little slimming
Thank you for your comments. The collar closes perfectly. There is 0.4 inch extra space so that the collar does not fit too tight around the neck. The picture may give a wrong impression. However, there is definitely some extra fabric around the chest and stomach. I do not prefer a very tight fit. The sleeves should be slimmer indeed. Any suggestions on how this should be done?

Originally Posted by Limniscate

Sleeves seem a little long like on my latest MTMs. Will it shrink with washings?
The shirt has not been washed yet. I guess the difference will not be that much. However, if the sleeves would be shorter the cuffs would not be visible while wearing a jacket.

 

[sartoriale1]

I uploaded a few pictures from another similar shirt. However, this one has been washed. The shirt has the same fit as the one shown above. This time I closed the collar. Please let me know what you think.

pic1 pic2 pic3

 

[orthofrancis]

Generally looks pretty good, if you are saying you don't like a tight fit. The sleeves on the second, washed, shirt look like they are going to be too short for a jacket.

Pic with a jacket?

 

[Threadbearer]

Originally Posted by sartoriale1

I would like to know what people think about the fit of my first made-to-measure shirt.
Please tell us who made it and for how much.

Please give me your opinions.

Please wash it three times, post pix, and ask again.

 

[bowtielover]

It's a little roomy, you might be able to get away fit a tailored fit shirt. Besides the shirt being a bit dressy for those jeans everything else seems to be in order.

 

[Shirtmaven]

these two shirts fit differently.
the second one.
chest is too tight.sleeves look short
cuffs too tight.
did youput this is a dryer?

 

[philosophe]

1. Wear and wash the shirt 3 times.
2. Never put a dress shirt in the dryer. Always hang dry.
3. If you still feel that the sleeves are too loose, take out just a tiny bit. Too slim, and you won't be able to move.
4. Check the fit in the chest area.

 

[sartoriale1]

Thanks for all your comments.

Originally Posted by orthofrancis

Generally looks pretty good, if you are saying you don't like a tight fit. The sleeves on the second, washed, shirt look like they are going to be too short for a jacket.

Pic with a jacket?

I will take a picture while wearing a jacket soon.

Originally Posted by Threadbearer

Please tell us who made it and for how much.

The shirt was made by a German company called Emanuel Berg. Their shirts are completely machine-made. The quality is comparable to that of the machine-made shirts by Lorenzini. Shirts are between 150 and 400 euro, depending on the chosen fabrics.

Originally Posted by bowtielover

It's a little roomy, you might be able to get away fit a tailored fit shirt. Besides the shirt being a bit dressy for those jeans everything else seems to be in order.

Do you really think the second shirt is roomy? I only wanted to show the fit of my shirt. I will not wear this shirt with jeans though.

Originally Posted by Shirtmaven

these two shirts fit differently.
the second one.
chest is too tight.sleeves look short
cuffs too tight.
did youput this is a dryer?

The shirts seem to have a different fit indeed. Can you please tell me why you think the chest of the second shirt is too tight? I noticed that the sleeves are a bit too short as well. Can you please tell me how tight the cuffs should be in your opinion? I did not use a dryer.

Originally Posted by philosophe

1. Wear and wash the shirt 3 times.

Can you please tell me why washing once would not be enough? By the way, I just washed the other shirt as well.