OK seriously, I don't get you guys. I have seen this very same AA cardigan, fitting the same way, on countless posts here. When Sauce and others wear a closer fit like this, you guys love it: Actually, I got a similar response on that first picture you posted, albeit a little toned down. A lot of people said it looked feminine, and while it took me a while to see it, I understand what they were saying. Also, the cardi in my pic is a little looser and longer than the one in yours.