These two shirtmakers come up a lot on the forum these days, so for the sake of science and posterity I thought I'd summarize my experience with both, and I hope anyone else who has tried both will speak up as well. Over the last few months I placed two orders each from both MyTailor.com and ModernTailor.com and wrote (brief) reviews on my site; you can read them here: MyTailor.com review ModernTailor.com review Manufacturing and Delivery The turnaround time on the shirts was: MyTailor order #1: 10 f**king weeks! MyTailor order #2: 4 weeks + 1 day ModernTailor order #1: 2 weeks ModernTailor order #2: 3 weeks + 1 day To be fair, that first amazingly quick ModernTailor order had my measurements all wrong. But their second (also very quick) delivery spanned a week-long Chinese holiday, otherwise it would have been even faster. Price and Value Average price for the MyTailor shirts was around $90. The ModernTailor ones were about half that. On the other hand, you can toss the MyTailor shirts in the wash and tumble dry, whereas ModernTailor shirts have to lie flat on a drying rack. If your time has value, the pain-in-the-ass factor needs to be considered. Fabric As far as the fabric is concerned, I love the heavy-duty material on the ModernTailor shirts. Great sheen, a bit of stretch. The most expensive MyTailor shirts I bought also have nice fabric, but one that I paid $90 for feels like flannel kids' pajamas after just two washes, and another I'd describe as just barely acceptable. Other Factors Both makers' shirts fit perfectly by the first or second order. The MyTailor shirts came with brass collar stays. ModernTailor ships with rather useless thin plastic ones. MyTailor's buttons were also heavier than ModernTailor's. Personally I've decided to go with ModernTailor for the foreseeable future. I like the quality and variety of fabrics, and you can't beat the price or the turnaround speed. I thank you for your time.