My Take on the Noguchi Table Replica vs. Real Deal Debate

[bugmenot2]

So after reading tons of forum posts and weighing everyone’s advice on whether to splurge on the “real” Noguchi coffee table or go with a replica, I decided to take the plunge with a high-quality replica. I know the authentic Noguchi from Herman Miller has a reputation for incredible craftsmanship, but after thinking about what I wanted in my space—and seeing what others had to say—the replica felt like the better move for me.

Here’s why I’m happy with my choice. First, the tempered glass is nice and thick, which was essential since I’ve got a kid in the house. The base also has that substantial, sculptural feel I was after. Some people in the forums pointed out that knock-offs often look a bit “off” with thinner legs or overly shiny finishes, but the one I found has a matte, well-finished wood base that feels sturdy and doesn’t scream “replica.” It really does have the classic Noguchi vibe I was hoping for.

As much as I respect Herman Miller’s quality, the price difference was hard to ignore. I read a few people’s comments about how the original might retain resale value, but honestly, I’m more interested in enjoying the piece long-term than worrying about resale.

For anyone considering a replica versus the original, I’d say a good replica can get you really close to that iconic look without the full investment. It’s a great choice if you love the design but want to keep things budget-friendly.

 

[Oswald Cornelius]

If you "love design" you'd buy an original. Kinda the way it works.

 

[Mujib]

If you love humanity, you’d buy an original.