Morning vs Evening - NewYorkIslander vs NewYorkInslander - Fit Battle 4/10/13

[StyleforumRobot]

Morning



Evening

 

[SpooPoker]

I vote for Rob

 

[Orgetorix]

Are my eyes playing tricks, or is "Evening" actually two different blue fabrics?

 

[FillW]

Different jackets and ties?

 

[mack11211]

Not a fair fit fight, as one is buttoned and the other is not.

 

[Knowledge is King]



Are my eyes playing tricks, or is "Evening" actually two different blue fabrics?

Your eyes are not playing tricks on you. That is two different blue fabrics.

 

[Peter1]

The evening fit would be perfect if jacket matched pants and if tie was smidgen wider. I don't have a lot of rules but you can't have same color suiting separate in different fabric. But I commend NYR, er, I, on nailing the fit. I'm not totally convinced that the morning tie works with the SC. I know he's a tie guy but I'd have gone with no tie and BD collar.

 

[EliodA]

Morning outift flatters his complexion and the loud tie suits him well. Also, gotta love the bag
Evening fit is a lot worse. The aformentioned clashing fabrics, the sleeves are too long. And the lapels are too narrow, so his head seems to be huge. On top of that, the too skinny, pale tie is just meh, IMO.

 

[in stitches]

great concept, robot. you have outdone yourself.