Here are fit pics. The jacket is a size large. I am wearing a thick Barbour lambswool crew neck sweater. For reference, I am 5' 10", 170 lbs. and a size 40 jacket. I am pleased with the jacket. The fit is slim but I have room in it. My torso is wide so it may look more fitted than it is. In my opinion, the jacket is not very oily. The construction looks and feels great. I expect to have this piece for many years. I'm probably sensitive to the oil because I have a lot of photography gear. Fingerprints were everywhere. Looking at your photo though it's obvious it's saturated. Not saying that's a bad thing for everyone- it's just a very rich garment even compared to the regular Filson oilcloth. Interesting to see exitstrategy's jacket seems less wet, I wonder if there's some variance going on here or if it's just lighting and photo. I think the consensus on the large is it's a 40" with layers or a 42" without, so that seems about right. It will be interesting to see how it ages. I wish I could get an XL to try on. I haven't completely given up although the Filson 5165 seems like a more "mature" alternative for me. I'm so OCD I'll probably wind up getting ahold of both and seeing what works best. Although if I keep OCD'ing on Aldens I'll be broke and begging for handouts soon.