pkincy
Senior Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2006
- Messages
- 949
- Reaction score
- 83
My first Jantzen came in (sorry no pixs as it is still unironed). And my first MyTailor.com shirt had come in a couple of weeks ago.
Initial impressions however give the nod to MyTailor.com. By a fairly wide margin.
The fabric is much nicer. On the Jantzen I picked the white fabric everyone seems to like (#22 superfine twill). And on the MyTailor shirt I picked a mid to low price cotton fabric also in all white. Much much silkier in the MyTailor shirt. The fit in the MyTailor shirt is better than excellent. The fit in the Jantzen shirt is a bit odd. The back and shoulders don't seem to lay as nicely. The regular fit in both gives plenty of room (without excess) in the MyTailor and in the Jantzen seems at this point (prewashing) to be a bit tight.
This is with the exact same measurements sent to each.
I will repost to this thread if it seems at all active in a week or so after I have had a chance to iron, wear, launder and rewear the Jantzen. On the MyTailor I have ironed, worn (twice actually), laundered and am awaiting the next wearing. But at 2 to 3 times the price I initially believe that the MyTailor shirt is the better value.
Of course if you need mtm and price is a major or even the only issue than Jantzen must get the nod.
Perry
Initial impressions however give the nod to MyTailor.com. By a fairly wide margin.
The fabric is much nicer. On the Jantzen I picked the white fabric everyone seems to like (#22 superfine twill). And on the MyTailor shirt I picked a mid to low price cotton fabric also in all white. Much much silkier in the MyTailor shirt. The fit in the MyTailor shirt is better than excellent. The fit in the Jantzen shirt is a bit odd. The back and shoulders don't seem to lay as nicely. The regular fit in both gives plenty of room (without excess) in the MyTailor and in the Jantzen seems at this point (prewashing) to be a bit tight.
This is with the exact same measurements sent to each.
I will repost to this thread if it seems at all active in a week or so after I have had a chance to iron, wear, launder and rewear the Jantzen. On the MyTailor I have ironed, worn (twice actually), laundered and am awaiting the next wearing. But at 2 to 3 times the price I initially believe that the MyTailor shirt is the better value.
Of course if you need mtm and price is a major or even the only issue than Jantzen must get the nod.
Perry