It took a whole month or so after receiving the Redmond III for me to finally wear them because the weather has been super nasty here. They are simply beautiful, and they really come to life under natural light. The fit is near perfect, if not perfect. The length of the last is ideal for me, and while it seems like it is narrow in the toe box from my point of view, it's width is actually perfect. I will say that the instep is a bit "fat", if that makes sense, but it isn't overly spacious and is again a perfect fit. It would have been nicer if it was less voluminous, but that doesn't take away from the fact that these shoes look fantastic. Because of that, my feet weren't in pain whatsoever. The only cosmetic flaw I noticed was in the broguing beside the lacing on the right shoe, where one of the holes is misaligned. It's pretty annoying because I'm a stickler for precision, but it's not a huge flaw. Just something to keep in mind for you, Justin. Apart from that, I'm very pleased with these. Easy 9/10.