As Robert said, definitely the Harris Tweed. I've tried all three. The brown herringbone is the worst of the (not necessarily bad mind you). Had some fuzz already off it. The navy is nice, but the shoulders went out too far on the side. The Harris Tweed is great, but I'm just not sold on the length. I was told it looked fine by people I trust, but I'm just holding off for now. The rest of the jacket is great though.