Help me choose the best shirt fit (poll)

[capersnsardines]

Hi everyone! Could you please give me some feedback on the fit of these shirts? I'm planning to order some shirts from collaro (dot) co, but I'm unsure whether I should use the measurements from these shirts or look for something different. For example, should I consider a different style, size, or something else?

I plan to wear them with a navy suit or jeans. Thanks!

EDIT: I thought I added a poll to this post, but it seems I made a mistake. However, please feel free to comment on the shirts. Do you like any of them in particular, or should I consider a different style? If so, what would you recommend?

Shirt 1

Shirt 2

Shirt 3

Shirt 4

 

[SteveMc]

Neck - fit looks ok.
Torso - looks like you could take in a bit. There's a lot of weight for personal preferences here. Some like it a bit more close fitting, some like having more room.
Sleeves - it is impossible to judge sleeve length because you have your hands in your pockets.

 

[capersnsardines]

Neck - fit looks ok.
Torso - looks like you could take in a bit. There's a lot of weight for personal preferences here. Some like it a bit more close fitting, some like having more room.
Sleeves - it is impossible to judge sleeve length because you have your hands in your pockets.

Thanks!.The sleeves are probably ok, not too short I think. I would ask my tailor for an opinion, but I don't really have one that I trust yet. My preference is not slim at all, if anything I have anti-slim preference.

Maybe I should do a better job ironing or something? I just dry the on the rack in our drying cabinet.