• I'm happy to introduce the Styleforum Happy Hour, our brand new podcast featuring lively discussion about menswear and the fashion industry. In the inaugural edition, a discussion of what's going on in retail today. Please check it out on the Journal. All episodes will be also be available soon on your favorite podcast platform.

  • Styleforum Gives - Holiday Charity Auction 8: Cuir de Russie card case from Equus Leather

    We are very proud to present this year's edition of the Styleforum Holiday Charity Auctions, this year in support of the Ronald McDonald House Charities of Spokane (www.rmhcspokane.org). Each Auction lasts 24 hours. Please follow and bid on all the auctions.

    The 8th auction is for a Cuir de Russie card case from Equus Leather. Please bid often and generously here

    Fok and the Styleforum Team.

  • STYLE. COMMUNITY. GREAT CLOTHING.

    Bored of counting likes on social networks? At Styleforum, you’ll find rousing discussions that go beyond strings of emojis.

    Click Here to join Styleforum's thousands of style enthusiasts today!

Help me choose: beech VS cedar shoetrees

40kaas-nl

Senior Member
Joined
May 16, 2006
Messages
196
Reaction score
0
Really need to buy some decent shoetrees for all my recent shoe purchases
I like these trees made from beech and the are only €22! They are not varnished, that is a good thing... right?
http://pbolten.free.fr/essais/en-us/dept_8.html But the same site also has shoetrees made from cedar wood (€35). Are these really superior to the beech ones? And does the difference justify the price? (Pure functionally, I do not mind the plain look of the beech ones). Thanks
 

mrchapel

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2006
Messages
679
Reaction score
1
Stay clear from beechwood shoe trees. Your best bet will be any that are made from cedar wood. I am not sure of the shopping conditions in the Netherlands, but I would imagine you could find some considerably cheaper at some local shops there.

Also, yes any wood that is varnished is moot and you might as well use plastic shoe trees if you're going that route.
 

bengal-stripe

Distinguished Member
Dubiously Honored
Joined
Mar 23, 2002
Messages
4,540
Reaction score
991
It doesn't make any difference whether you choose birch or cedar. Birch is a European, cedar an American wood. Until the 1950s or 60s the American wood of choice was maple; when that became too expensive, cedar was chosen.

All the European bespoke firms make their shoe trees in European hardwood.
 

Artisan Fan

Suitsupply-sider
Joined
Jul 17, 2006
Messages
32,372
Reaction score
191
Obeche perhaps but not beech.

Cedar for longer-term storage.
 

16520Man

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2006
Messages
372
Reaction score
8
Cedar trees by all means; they wick moisture very well and keep your shoes smelling fresh. I do suggest you check out bexley.fr; they just got in a new shipment of trees.
 

JLibourel

Distinguished Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2004
Messages
8,754
Reaction score
467
Originally Posted by bengal-stripe
It doesn't make any difference whether you choose birch or cedar. Birch is a European, cedar an American wood. Until the 1950s or 60s the American wood of choice was maple; when that became too expensive, cedar was chosen.

All the European bespoke firms make their shoe trees in European hardwood.


Bengal-stripe, normally I hold your knowledge in the highest regard, but I've got to question this assertion of yours. I thought cedar was desirable precisely because it was a porous, highly absorbent softwood. An additional bonus is that it is so aromatic. Birch and maple are hardwoods--both, especially birch, being used in the manufacture of gunstocks, inter alia. If the woods used are inconsequential, why don't they just manufacture them from pine and cut the costs accordingly?
 

mrchapel

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2006
Messages
679
Reaction score
1
Originally Posted by JLibourel
Bengal-stripe, normally I hold your knowledge in the highest regard, but I've got to question this assertion of yours. I thought cedar was desirable precisely because it was a porous, highly absorbent softwood. An additional bonus is that it is so aromatic. Birch and maple are hardwoods--both, especially birch, being used in the manufacture of gunstocks, inter alia. If the woods used are inconsequential, why don't they just manufacture them from pine and cut the costs accordingly?

I, too, question the assertion and am in agreement with you in regards to the reasoning for using cedar wood as opposed to other woods. I have always been taught that cedar is the best without question.
 

Tomasso

Distinguished Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2006
Messages
4,078
Reaction score
13
Originally Posted by mrchapel
I have always been taught that cedar is the best without question.

Lobb uses mahogany.
 

Huntsman

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2004
Messages
7,797
Reaction score
565
I really rather doubt if cedar is an American wood -- perhaps the use of cedar for trees began here, but what of the famed cedars of Lebanon?

I just like the smell.

Regards,
Huntsman
 

RIDER

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2004
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
133
I completely agree with bengal-stripe...the advertised benefits of cedar are as much marketing as fact. I have many shoe trees from both Woodlore and Rochester, and Beech trees from Dasco and the Dasco are far superior, IMO. The cost, of course, is far greater as well. Lime is also a very nice wood to use in shoe trees.

Both woods are porous, and therefore perform the basic task of absorbing moisture from the linings of shoes. Cedar has become the wood of choice here due to its low cost. Not sure if the cedar used by the 2 American manufacturers is of US origin, but I do know that you can buy 50,000 BF quantities of cedar from Peru for around $.04 per BF. Also, this comes into the US duty-free while the EU subjects it to tariffs. Beech, on the other hand, is readily sourced at reasonable prices from the Baltic states, from what I am told, inside the EU. Again, I don't know if this cedar is used or not, but the bottom line is cedar is very cheap.

I have quite a few cedar trees that are split/chipped, or have bled enough that the springs have become clogged and therefore almost useless while my beech and lime trees are perfect 5 years along...

If the woods used are inconsequential, why don't they just manufacture them from pine and cut the costs accordingly?
cedar is pine
 

RIDER

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2004
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
133
I completely agree with bengal-stripe...the advertised benefits of cedar are as much marketing as fact. I have many shoe trees from both Woodlore and Rochester, and Beech trees from Dasco and the Dasco are far superior, IMO. The cost, of course, is far greater as well. Lime is also a very nice wood to use in shoe trees.

Both woods are porous, and therefore perform the basic task of absorbing moisture from the linings of shoes. Cedar has become the wood of choice here due to its low cost. Not sure if the cedar used by the 2 American manufacturers is of US origin, but I do know that you can buy 50,000 BF quantities of cedar from Peru for around $.04 per BF. Also, this comes into the US duty-free while the EU subjects it to tariffs. Beech, on the other hand, is readily sourced at reasonable prices from the Baltic states, from what I am told, inside the EU. Again, I don't know if this cedar is used or not, but the bottom line is cedar is very cheap.

I have quite a few cedar trees that are split/chipped, or have bled enough that the springs have become clogged and therefore almost useless while my beech and lime trees are perfect 5 years along...

If the woods used are inconsequential, why don't they just manufacture them from pine and cut the costs accordingly?
cedar is pine
 

JLibourel

Distinguished Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2004
Messages
8,754
Reaction score
467
A few minutes research on the Net reveals that the true cedars (genus cedrus) are strictly old-world plants. I suspect the cedar used by Woodlore (and maybe Rochester) is Western Red Cedar, which is not a real cedar but actually a tree of the genus thuja.

Thus, real cedar is anything but "an American wood."

However, between Bengal-stripe and Ron Rider, I shall certainly defer to their superior knowledge.
 

whoopee

Distinguished Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
2,455
Reaction score
4
European shoemakers have told me pretty much what bengal and rider have indicated: nothing special about cedar.
 

rnoldh

Stylish Dinosaur
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
16,909
Reaction score
2,999
Originally Posted by Artisan Fan
Obeche perhaps but not beech.

Cedar for longer-term storage.


I imagine Jason Amesbury uses obeche, but do you know if obeche is readily available in the US at competitive prices. I mean $50 or less per pair of obeche trees?

BTW: Your thread on your Bespoke shoe experience is fascinating and informative! Thanks
 

Styleforum is proudly sponsored by

Featured Sponsor

How many pairs of shoes do you own?

  • 1 - 4

    Votes: 30 3.6%
  • 5 - 10

    Votes: 143 17.4%
  • 11 - 20

    Votes: 270 32.8%
  • 21 - 30

    Votes: 130 15.8%
  • 31 - 40

    Votes: 70 8.5%
  • 41 - 50

    Votes: 48 5.8%
  • 51 - 60

    Votes: 25 3.0%
  • 61 - 70

    Votes: 22 2.7%
  • 71 - 80

    Votes: 17 2.1%
  • 81 - 90

    Votes: 7 0.9%
  • 91 - 100

    Votes: 9 1.1%
  • 100+

    Votes: 52 6.3%

Related Threads

Forum statistics

Threads
429,099
Messages
9,228,621
Members
193,720
Latest member
viaiulamain
Top