Help Deciding Best Women's Coat/Sweater

[lilkatalyst]

Well, I'm deciding on which coat/sweater I should get for my cousin in Australia and wanted to get some opinions/suggestions about which one be nice for the winter and going out. If you guys happen to know some nicer coat/sweaters, let me know! Thanks everyone!

There's also a white color one for #1:
1

2

3

4

 

[8bpc]

1 and 2 are interesting, although that funky shiny material on the pockets/back bothers me. Who makes those? What site are those photos from?

 

[Listi]

The second one looks the best to me, although that shiny square on the back is irritating.

 

[lilkatalyst]

Originally Posted by 8bpc

1 and 2 are interesting, although that funky shiny material on the pockets/back bothers me. Who makes those? What site are those photos from?
The first 3 pictures are Mackage brand coats and last one is a Ralph Lauren. http://www.mackage.com/app/webroot/s...cat=wools&pg=1 I just got an email back from my cousin in Australia and she said don't worry about getting her sweaters or coat! Boo.. Oh well, thank you everyone for the help though.

 

[FashionIQ]

I like 3 as well. Could be because I find the model very attractive, though.

 

[Hard2Fit]

I like #4 with #3 coming in a distant second.
I do not like #1 or #2.

 

[Mauro]

I carry mackage and they sell VERY well for me. If you go with one of their coats she won't be disappointed.